Home Page link

If Hitler Approached You...

Architecture and Design - Building design/construction and related topics. 

Page 2 of 6       < 1 2 3 > last >> Bookmark this page:  YahooMyWeb Yahoo!  Google Google  Windows Live Favorites Windows Live  del.icio.us del.icio.us  digg digg  Add to Netscape Netscape
Subject Author Date
If Hitler Approached You... Warm Worm 05-11-2007
If you were  Registered and logged in, you could reply and use other advanced thread options
Posted by Marianne Bloss on May 11, 2007, 12:35 pm
Warm Worm wrote:

> ... as a prospective client, (making the obvious assumptions-- ie,
> it's the 30's...) what would you do?

There was a documentation on German TV about Albert Speer. He appeared
to be just like many other architects: ambituous and dedicated to some
luxury. Watching the story of his life...I couldn't tell what I would do
in this situation...but then, considering my own attitude...I think I
would stick to Mies :-)

Marianne

PexSupply Save 50 468x60
Posted by =?ISO-8859-1?Q?Se=F1or_Popcorn on May 11, 2007, 7:18 pm
Marianne Bloss wrote:
> Warm Worm wrote:
>
>> ... as a prospective client, (making the obvious assumptions-- ie,
>> it's the 30's...) what would you do?
>
> There was a documentation on German TV about Albert Speer. He appeared
> to be just like many other architects: ambituous and dedicated to some
> luxury. Watching the story of his life...I couldn't tell what I would do
> in this situation...

Paul (3D Peruna) does have a point about the retrospective nature of the
question. For me, it might be a question of how much I knew about the
client at the time.

> but then, considering my own attitude...I think I would stick to Mies :-)

Ah yes, Mies...

Your response about him, and his history, as well as the responses of
the rest of this thread spawns some reflection about influence;
affluence, or lack thereof; personal convictions and what history
eventually reads as.

"After 1933, Nazi political pressure soon forced Mies to close the
government-financed school, a victim of its previous association with
socialism, communism, and other progressive ideologies. He built very
little in these years (one built commission was Philip Johnson's New
York apartment); his style was rejected by the Nazis as not 'German' in
character. Frustrated and unhappy, he left his homeland reluctantly in
1937 as he saw his opportunity for any future building commissions
vanish..."
-- Wikipedia.org

Posted by Marianne Bloss on May 12, 2007, 10:59 am
Seņor Popcorn-Coconut wrote:
> Marianne Bloss wrote:
>> Warm Worm wrote:
>>
>>> ... as a prospective client, (making the obvious assumptions-- ie,
>>> it's the 30's...) what would you do?
>>
>> There was a documentation on German TV about Albert Speer. He appeared
>> to be just like many other architects: ambituous and dedicated to some
>> luxury. Watching the story of his life...I couldn't tell what I would do
>> in this situation...
>
> Paul (3D Peruna) does have a point about the retrospective nature of the
> question. For me, it might be a question of how much I knew about the
> client at the time.

True, and I also appreciate the other views, but maybe it's too
hypothetic a question.

Marianne

> Ah yes, Mies...
>
> Your response about him, and his history, as well as the responses of
> the rest of this thread spawns some reflection about influence;
> affluence, or lack thereof; personal convictions and what history
> eventually reads as.
>
> "After 1933, Nazi political pressure soon forced Mies to close the
> government-financed school, a victim of its previous association with
> socialism, communism, and other progressive ideologies. He built very
> little in these years (one built commission was Philip Johnson's New
> York apartment); his style was rejected by the Nazis as not 'German' in
> character. Frustrated and unhappy, he left his homeland reluctantly in
> 1937 as he saw his opportunity for any future building commissions
> vanish..."
> -- Wikipedia.org






Posted by Michael Bulatovich on May 12, 2007, 2:17 pm

> Seņor Popcorn-Coconut wrote:
>> Marianne Bloss wrote:
>>> Warm Worm wrote:
>>>
>>>> ... as a prospective client, (making the obvious assumptions-- ie,
>>>> it's the 30's...) what would you do?
>>>
>>> There was a documentation on German TV about Albert Speer. He appeared
>>> to be just like many other architects: ambituous and dedicated to some
>>> luxury. Watching the story of his life...I couldn't tell what I would do
>>> in this situation...
>>
>> Paul (3D Peruna) does have a point about the retrospective nature of the
>> question. For me, it might be a question of how much I knew about the
>> client at the time.
>
> True, and I also appreciate the other views, but maybe it's too
> hypothetic a question.

It comes very close to being a troll, as it approaches Godwin's Law.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Godwin's_Law
--


MichaelB
www.michaelbulatovich.ca



Posted by Marianne Bloss on May 12, 2007, 3:08 pm
Michael Bulatovich wrote:
>>> Paul (3D Peruna) does have a point about the retrospective nature of the
>>> question. For me, it might be a question of how much I knew about the
>>> client at the time.
>>
>> True, and I also appreciate the other views, but maybe it's too
>> hypothetic a question.
>
> It comes very close to being a troll, as it approaches Godwin's Law.
>
> http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Godwin's_Law

:-))

Well, I personally wouldn't go further than saying that the original
question is quite away from reality, but it has been discussed in a
distinguished way.

As for your point of view, I am with you :-)

Marianne



Page 2 of 6       < 1 2 3 > last >>
Similar ThreadsPosted
If GWB Approached You... May 9, 2007, 3:49 pm

Contact Us | Privacy Policy

XML SitemapXML Sitemap