Home Page link

Existing Water Tank Support

Building Construction - Building Construction Industry Discussions. 

Page 1 of 2       1 2 > last >> Bookmark this page:  YahooMyWeb Yahoo!  Google Google  Windows Live Favorites Windows Live  del.icio.us del.icio.us  digg digg  Add to Netscape Netscape
Subject Author Date
Existing Water Tank Support jloomis 08-28-2007
If you were  Registered and logged in, you could reply and use other advanced thread options
Posted by jloomis on August 28, 2007, 9:23 pm
I looked at a 16 ft. diameter, 45 ft circumference and 10 ft. height for an
existing Redwood Water Tank.
It is full of water.........
It is supported underneath by 4x6 and posts about everywhere.
The foundation is faulty, the water is necessary for the Trailer Park and
the owner wants me to pour a concrete slab under
that..............tank......
There is no room to speak of, lifting the tank is out of the question, a
decent footing, and steel in a slab would be impossible to do.
The tank leaks also...........
What does the owner think?
The ground under the tank is wet and soggy.........
You cannot crawl under it.
The tank also has sides that go down past the floor. The floor is keyed
into the wall. Steel straps support the sides of the tank.
What does a guy do?
You cannot drain the tank...........hum?
any ideas?
jloomis



Posted by Andy Asberry on August 28, 2007, 11:10 pm
wrote:

>I looked at a 16 ft. diameter, 45 ft circumference and 10 ft. height for an
>existing Redwood Water Tank.
>It is full of water.........
>It is supported underneath by 4x6 and posts about everywhere.
>The foundation is faulty, the water is necessary for the Trailer Park and
>the owner wants me to pour a concrete slab under
>that..............tank......
>There is no room to speak of, lifting the tank is out of the question, a
>decent footing, and steel in a slab would be impossible to do.
>The tank leaks also...........
>What does the owner think?
>The ground under the tank is wet and soggy.........
>You cannot crawl under it.
>The tank also has sides that go down past the floor. The floor is keyed
>into the wall. Steel straps support the sides of the tank.
>What does a guy do?
>You cannot drain the tank...........hum?
>any ideas?
>jloomis
>

Just the water weighs 125,000 pounds.

Bring in a temp tank or truck. Pump the water into the temp and hook
up temporarily. The waterlogged tank may weigh 10,000#. If it is
leaking, it needs reworking or the bands tightened. It can be moved
intact using cable bridles and a pretty stought crane. Either move it
aside while pouring the slab or pour next to it and move it over. When
setting it down, make sure the 4x4s are perpendicular to the bottom
planks.

Posted by jloomis on August 28, 2007, 11:46 pm
Thanks for the thoughts.
I spoke with the owner concerning these issues.
I would be afraid to lift the tank since it is "grandfathered into its area,
and "settled" in a way that putting a new foundation under it would give it
a new posture.(leaks)
tough one.
Hey, Thanks for the ideas.
jloomis
> wrote:
>
>>I looked at a 16 ft. diameter, 45 ft circumference and 10 ft. height for
>>an
>>existing Redwood Water Tank.
>>It is full of water.........
>>It is supported underneath by 4x6 and posts about everywhere.
>>The foundation is faulty, the water is necessary for the Trailer Park and
>>the owner wants me to pour a concrete slab under
>>that..............tank......
>>There is no room to speak of, lifting the tank is out of the question, a
>>decent footing, and steel in a slab would be impossible to do.
>>The tank leaks also...........
>>What does the owner think?
>>The ground under the tank is wet and soggy.........
>>You cannot crawl under it.
>>The tank also has sides that go down past the floor. The floor is keyed
>>into the wall. Steel straps support the sides of the tank.
>>What does a guy do?
>>You cannot drain the tank...........hum?
>>any ideas?
>>jloomis
>>
>
> Just the water weighs 125,000 pounds.
>
> Bring in a temp tank or truck. Pump the water into the temp and hook
> up temporarily. The waterlogged tank may weigh 10,000#. If it is
> leaking, it needs reworking or the bands tightened. It can be moved
> intact using cable bridles and a pretty stought crane. Either move it
> aside while pouring the slab or pour next to it and move it over. When
> setting it down, make sure the 4x4s are perpendicular to the bottom
> planks.



Posted by Bobk207 on August 29, 2007, 11:37 am
> I looked at a 16 ft. diameter, 45 ft circumference and 10 ft. height for an
> existing Redwood Water Tank.
> It is full of water.........
> It is supported underneath by 4x6 and posts about everywhere.
> The foundation is faulty, the water is necessary for the Trailer Park and
> the owner wants me to pour a concrete slab under
> that..............tank......
> There is no room to speak of, lifting the tank is out of the question, a
> decent footing, and steel in a slab would be impossible to do.
> The tank leaks also...........
> What does the owner think?
> The ground under the tank is wet and soggy.........
> You cannot crawl under it.
> The tank also has sides that go down past the floor. The floor is keyed
> into the wall. Steel straps support the sides of the tank.
> What does a guy do?
> You cannot drain the tank...........hum?
> any ideas?
> jloomis

jloomis-

You've got a tough one there. Owner / situation is placing so many
constraints on the system that is will be close to impossible to fix
it properly.

As Andy said, you've got ~15,000 gallons ~125,000 lbs of water & my
estimate ~ 6,000 lbs of water logged tank.

The leaking tank has caused the soil to fail. You need a redwood tank
expert (is the tank in Northern Cal? Mendo?) My suggestion would be
to try to stop the leaks OR collect the leaking water & channel (or
pump) it away so the soil can dry out.

It's going to be very difficult to deal with the soil while its
soggy.

Andy's suggestion of the temp water system / tank is the way to go.

Get the leaks under control, let the local soil dry out (trench & pump
or drain). Consider a new slab very nearby (if the soil is dry
enough). Build a new slab, crane the tank onto the new slab & refill
it. Fix the leaks (tighen straps as you go) or just properly deal
with the leakage water.....are be talking about gallons per minute or
gallons per day?

If you can pour a new slab you'll only have to crane the tank once.
If the tank has to wind up back in the same place you'll need two
crane visits. :(

A 16' x 16' (min) concrete slab of decent thickness (& the dry soil
under it) will easily support the full tank but with saturated soil
you'll always be in trouble.

You need a decent foundation with a provision to handle any potential
water leaks, like a curb & a sump or drainage channel depending on the
relative elevations of things.

That redwood tank should be very forgiving of repositioning, it wood &
wet.

Maybe the owner should consider selling the redwood & using the $'s to
buy a new plastic or metal tank. It's most likely old growth r/
w...worth a fair amount for sliding & trim.

This is relatively simple job IF the owner allows you some wiggle
room.

cheers
Bob





Posted by jloomis on August 29, 2007, 8:28 pm
Thanks for your information.
There are a lot of problems with this situation.
One is that this is a trailer park with little or no room.
The water is used by the residents.
The tank leaks like a sieve.......
The side are longer than the bottom..........
A foundation would need to be built that would support the floor and let the
side hang down.
The soil is compromised........
The best thisng to do is build a foundation elsewhere and put new tanks on
it.....Plastic.......
Anyway........the owner realizes the situation and his Dad put this in 24
years ago on post and beam.......4x6.......on earth.......
It is not a simple fix.
jloomis Mendocino County
>> I looked at a 16 ft. diameter, 45 ft circumference and 10 ft. height for
>> an
>> existing Redwood Water Tank.
>> It is full of water.........
>> It is supported underneath by 4x6 and posts about everywhere.
>> The foundation is faulty, the water is necessary for the Trailer Park and
>> the owner wants me to pour a concrete slab under
>> that..............tank......
>> There is no room to speak of, lifting the tank is out of the question, a
>> decent footing, and steel in a slab would be impossible to do.
>> The tank leaks also...........
>> What does the owner think?
>> The ground under the tank is wet and soggy.........
>> You cannot crawl under it.
>> The tank also has sides that go down past the floor. The floor is keyed
>> into the wall. Steel straps support the sides of the tank.
>> What does a guy do?
>> You cannot drain the tank...........hum?
>> any ideas?
>> jloomis
>
> jloomis-
>
> You've got a tough one there. Owner / situation is placing so many
> constraints on the system that is will be close to impossible to fix
> it properly.
>
> As Andy said, you've got ~15,000 gallons ~125,000 lbs of water & my
> estimate ~ 6,000 lbs of water logged tank.
>
> The leaking tank has caused the soil to fail. You need a redwood tank
> expert (is the tank in Northern Cal? Mendo?) My suggestion would be
> to try to stop the leaks OR collect the leaking water & channel (or
> pump) it away so the soil can dry out.
>
> It's going to be very difficult to deal with the soil while its
> soggy.
>
> Andy's suggestion of the temp water system / tank is the way to go.
>
> Get the leaks under control, let the local soil dry out (trench & pump
> or drain). Consider a new slab very nearby (if the soil is dry
> enough). Build a new slab, crane the tank onto the new slab & refill
> it. Fix the leaks (tighen straps as you go) or just properly deal
> with the leakage water.....are be talking about gallons per minute or
> gallons per day?
>
> If you can pour a new slab you'll only have to crane the tank once.
> If the tank has to wind up back in the same place you'll need two
> crane visits. :(
>
> A 16' x 16' (min) concrete slab of decent thickness (& the dry soil
> under it) will easily support the full tank but with saturated soil
> you'll always be in trouble.
>
> You need a decent foundation with a provision to handle any potential
> water leaks, like a curb & a sump or drainage channel depending on the
> relative elevations of things.
>
> That redwood tank should be very forgiving of repositioning, it wood &
> wet.
>
> Maybe the owner should consider selling the redwood & using the $'s to
> buy a new plastic or metal tank. It's most likely old growth r/
> w...worth a fair amount for sliding & trim.
>
> This is relatively simple job IF the owner allows you some wiggle
> room.
>
> cheers
> Bob
>
>
>
>



Page 1 of 2       1 2 > last >>
Similar ThreadsPosted
Hot Water tank Anode rod and Water softner June 9, 2007, 12:42 pm
Water Well Pressure Tank September 10, 2006, 11:05 am
Hot water tank return October 28, 2006, 8:36 pm
well-water captive air tank February 28, 2007, 8:57 pm
Construction of Concrete Water Storage Tank January 7, 2007, 7:24 am
home made corrugaetd rain water tank October 18, 2007, 1:05 am
Skid foundation support October 16, 2006, 10:38 pm
foundation window support April 13, 2007, 3:11 pm
Replace Support Trilam May 25, 2008, 10:44 am
screw jack support posts April 12, 2007, 8:35 pm

Contact Us | Privacy Policy

XML SitemapXML Sitemap