Home Page link

Redoing garage concrete floor - Page 2

Building Construction - Building Construction Industry Discussions. 

Page 2 of 2       << first < 1 2 Bookmark this page:  YahooMyWeb Yahoo!  Google Google  Windows Live Favorites Windows Live  del.icio.us del.icio.us  digg digg  Add to Netscape Netscape
Subject Author Date
Redoing garage concrete floor saka 10-11-2009
If you were  Registered and logged in, you could reply and use other advanced thread options
Posted by fftt on October 12, 2009, 11:12 am


> A person would need help.
n message
> On Oct 11, 6:52 pm, sakatumi21_at_gmail_dot_...@foo.com (saka) wrote:
> > saka had written this in response
> > tohttp://www.thestuccocompany.com/construction/Re-Redoing-garage-concre=
...
> > :
> > jloomis wrote:
> > > Hi,
> > > Is the existing subgrade acceptable?
> > Not yet. We are at this stage now, dig up the soil, lay the vapour shee=
t,
> > tamper the sand and gravel.> Are you preparing that so that the "same"
> > does not occur?
> > That is the plan, how deep should the sand/gravel be? 1 inch ?
> > > In any case, pouring concrete in a confined area presents problems...=
..
> > > The same story as painting yourself into a corner.
> > > There must be some doors....and or windows? (access)
> > Yes there is a large roller door/side door that can be accessed from th=
e
> > front.
> > > You can use overhead screed boards on the left and right sides so tha=
t
> > > there
> > > will be no stakes in the concrete pour.
> > How exactly do these overhead screed boards work? since there is no
> > formwork on the right and left hand sides.
> > > Down the center a person can use a metal buried screed form, that
> > > represents
> > > top of concrete and rod off of that. It remains in the concrete and
> > > acts as
> > > a "cold" joint, or expansion / contraction line.....
> > I found a site metalscreed.com so I now have an idea of what these are.
> > Are these expensive? and could they be used on the left and right sides=
as
> > well instead of using the overhead screeed?
> > > I would make sure to use a "grid" of re-bar in the slab to
> > > keep the concrete
> > > together. I have had more luck with re-bar and cracking than any
> > > concrete
> > > wire or 6-6 10-10 mesh used.....
> > > Also keeping the rebar at the right height is important so that it do=
es
> > > not
> > > get imbedded in the sub-grade.
> > > Are you using a vapor barrier?
> > > If so, I always make sure it is deep enough to cover with a layer of
> > > sand to
> > > facilitate concrete pouring.....I never pour on plastic alone....
> > > It can create problems with water and finishing.......
> > > With concrete tools, I always jitter bug the top layer of
> > > concrete......always.
> > > It helps bring up the fines for the top finish, and set some of the
> > > larger
> > > rocks below top.
> > > Using a float on a long pole is helpful in a confined area....
> > > I have several mag floats for preliminary surface prep. and then stee=
l
> > > trowels on poles for finsih work.
> > > In the past 4 years I have purchased a power float.....that goes on
> > > poles
> > > also.
> > > It is a lifesaver......works wonderful.....can bull float the concret=
e
> > > as
> > > well as finish it all from outside the slab..........
> > > It weighs 24# and has a small gas engine......works great.
> > > Knee skids are also beneficial for finishing concrete in confined
> > > areas....
> > > I use metal, knee skids, and like "snow" skis.....you can
> > > move out over
> > > concrete without leaving board marks......of course there is a time
> > > when
> > > they are most successful as when the concrete is hard enough to use
> > > them.
> > > some of my inside pours I have pre-set boards high enough on the wall=
s
> > > that
> > > a plank can span the area being poured......
> > > You can "walk" a plank out and finsih an area without even
> > > getting in the
> > > concrete......an aluminum "rental plank works well......or a
> > > 2x12.....or
> > > scaffold plank.
> > > I do this a lot for colored or stenciled concrete where the surface
> > > cannot
> > > be walked on......
> > > have fun.
> > > I am sure I have missed something......
> > > jloomisconstruction and concrete
> > Thanks for your post, it is very much appreciated don't feel so lost no=
w
> > -------------------------------------
> saka-
> You got a lot of good information from jlloomis but I would advise
> against doing a confined flat work job of 500 sq ft (50 sq m) =A0as your
> first DIY attempt.
> cheers
> Bob

j-

I was getting total "rookie" vibes base on the OP & his
reply .......... but flat work scares me, so maybe its just my fear.

I've done a little flat work & I've seen experts do it......I prefer
to watch it done. :)
The results are much better.

Plus his original post, noting 1" gaps & 1/2" differentials has me a
bit concerned.
I'd hate for him to do all this work & have the new floor not work out
any better than the one he's replacing.

cheers
Bob




cheers
Bob

Posted by saka on October 12, 2009, 1:14 pm


saka had written this in response to
http://www.thestuccocompany.com/construction/Re-Redoing-garage-concrete-floor-18086-.htm
:

fftt wrote:

> wrote:
>> A person would need help.
>> I assume saka has some building sense?"fftt"
> n message
>> On Oct 11, 6:52 pm, sakatumi21_at_gmail_dot_...@foo.com (saka)
>> wrote:
>> > saka had written this in response
>>> tohttp://www.thestuccocompany.com/construction/Re-Redoing-garage-concre=
> ...
>> > :
>> > jloomis wrote:
>> > > Hi,
>> > > Is the existing subgrade acceptable?
>> > Not yet. We are at this stage now, dig up the soil, lay the
>>> vapour shee=
> t,
>> > tamper the sand and gravel.> Are you preparing that so
>>> that the "same"
>> > does not occur?
>> > That is the plan, how deep should the sand/gravel be? 1 inch
>>> ?
>> > > In any case, pouring concrete in a confined area
>>>> presents problems...=
> ..
>> > > The same story as painting yourself into a corner.
>> > > There must be some doors....and or windows? (access)
>> > Yes there is a large roller door/side door that can be
>>> accessed from th=
> e
>> > front.
>> > > You can use overhead screed boards on the left and right
>>>> sides so tha=
> t
>> > > there
>> > > will be no stakes in the concrete pour.
>> > How exactly do these overhead screed boards work? since there
>>> is no
>> > formwork on the right and left hand sides.
>> > > Down the center a person can use a metal buried screed
>>>> form, that
>> > > represents
>> > > top of concrete and rod off of that. It remains in the
>>>> concrete and
>> > > acts as
>> > > a "cold" joint, or expansion / contraction
>>>> line.....
>> > I found a site metalscreed.com so I now have an idea of what
>>> these are.
>> > Are these expensive? and could they be used on the left and
>>> right sides=
> as
>> > well instead of using the overhead screeed?
>> > > I would make sure to use a "grid" of re-bar in
>>>> the slab to
>> > > keep the concrete
>> > > together. I have had more luck with re-bar and cracking
>>>> than any
>> > > concrete
>> > > wire or 6-6 10-10 mesh used.....
>> > > Also keeping the rebar at the right height is important
>>>> so that it do=
> es
>> > > not
>> > > get imbedded in the sub-grade.
>> > > Are you using a vapor barrier?
>> > > If so, I always make sure it is deep enough to cover
>>>> with a layer of
>> > > sand to
>> > > facilitate concrete pouring.....I never pour on plastic
>>>> alone....
>> > > It can create problems with water and finishing.......
>> > > With concrete tools, I always jitter bug the top layer
>>>> of
>> > > concrete......always.
>> > > It helps bring up the fines for the top finish, and set
>>>> some of the
>> > > larger
>> > > rocks below top.
>> > > Using a float on a long pole is helpful in a confined
>>>> area....
>> > > I have several mag floats for preliminary surface prep.
>>>> and then stee=
> l
>> > > trowels on poles for finsih work.
>> > > In the past 4 years I have purchased a power
>>>> float.....that goes on
>> > > poles
>> > > also.
>> > > It is a lifesaver......works wonderful.....can bull
>>>> float the concret=
> e
>> > > as
>> > > well as finish it all from outside the slab..........
>> > > It weighs 24# and has a small gas engine......works
>>>> great.
>> > > Knee skids are also beneficial for finishing concrete in
>>>> confined
>> > > areas....
>> > > I use metal, knee skids, and like "snow"
>>>> skis.....you can
>> > > move out over
>> > > concrete without leaving board marks......of course
>>>> there is a time
>> > > when
>> > > they are most successful as when the concrete is hard
>>>> enough to use
>> > > them.
>> > > some of my inside pours I have pre-set boards high
>>>> enough on the wall=
> s
>> > > that
>> > > a plank can span the area being poured......
>> > > You can "walk" a plank out and finsih an area
>>>> without even
>> > > getting in the
>> > > concrete......an aluminum "rental plank works
>>>> well......or a
>> > > 2x12.....or
>> > > scaffold plank.
>> > > I do this a lot for colored or stenciled concrete where
>>>> the surface
>> > > cannot
>> > > be walked on......
>> > > have fun.
>> > > I am sure I have missed something......
>> > > jloomisconstruction and concrete
>> > Thanks for your post, it is very much appreciated don't feel
>>> so lost no=
> w
>> > -------------------------------------
>> saka-
>> You got a lot of good information from jlloomis but I would advise
>> against doing a confined flat work job of 500 sq ft (50 sq m)
>> =A0as your
>> first DIY attempt.
>> cheers
>> Bob

> j-

> I was getting total "rookie" vibes base on the OP & his
> reply .......... but flat work scares me, so maybe its just my fear.

> I've done a little flat work & I've seen experts do it......I
> prefer
> to watch it done. :)
> The results are much better.

> Plus his original post, noting 1" gaps & 1/2"
> differentials has me a
> bit concerned.
> I'd hate for him to do all this work & have the new floor not work
> out
> any better than the one he's replacing.

> cheers
> Bob




> cheers
> Bob

Thanks for the replies guys.

Pretty much am a total rookie, but didn't plan on doing this all myself
unless it was fairly straight forward, which it doesn't sound like it is.
Was hoping to get some info on how it is done (which I did so thank you)
so when I get quotes I can access if their method is good. I also have a
friend that does concreting but he is fairly new to it.

Yeah, it would not be good if the concrete turned as bad as before. But
most likely will be paying someone to do a proper job :)

Thanks again for the info
-------------------------------------




Posted by PeterD on October 12, 2009, 4:05 pm


On Mon, 12 Oct 2009 17:14:35 +0000,
sakatumi21_at_gmail_dot_com@foo.com (saka) wrote:
>Thanks for the replies guys.
>Pretty much am a total rookie, but didn't plan on doing this all myself
>unless it was fairly straight forward, which it doesn't sound like it is.
>Was hoping to get some info on how it is done (which I did so thank you)
>so when I get quotes I can access if their method is good. I also have a
>friend that does concreting but he is fairly new to it.
>Yeah, it would not be good if the concrete turned as bad as before. But
>most likely will be paying someone to do a proper job :)
>Thanks again for the info

Good. I'm relatively experienced at construction (not a pro, but I can
build) and I'd not try that slab myself. (I did a 10m x 20m
building/slab a couple of years ago, the only think I contracted out
was... The slab!)

Posted by RicodJour on October 13, 2009, 8:55 am


> Good. I'm relatively experienced at construction (not a pro, but I can
> build) and I'd not try that slab myself. (I did a 10m x 20m
> building/slab a couple of years ago, the only think I contracted out
> was... The slab!)

Okay, I gotta ask - is the slab the best or worst thing? ;)

R

Posted by PeterD on October 13, 2009, 12:34 pm


On Tue, 13 Oct 2009 05:55:42 -0700 (PDT), RicodJour

>> Good. I'm relatively experienced at construction (not a pro, but I can
>> build) and I'd not try that slab myself. (I did a 10m x 20m
>> building/slab a couple of years ago, the only think I contracted out
>> was... The slab!)
>Okay, I gotta ask - is the slab the best or worst thing? ;)
>R

Actually both turned out very well. I'd use the contractor again in a
minute, he did a credible job on the slab. The building turned out
very well too, better than I'd expected.

I've had to tell several friends that they can't move into my
garage... <bg>

Page 2 of 2       << first < 1 2
Similar ThreadsPosted
Old Garage Concrete Floor-Tile it or...... February 2, 2009, 10:12 am
redoing floor of fixing it? February 17, 2007, 4:37 pm
Adding 2nd floor above detached garage March 18, 2007, 7:07 pm
Concrete garage base August 11, 2006, 9:09 am
Concrete Questions for Garage Construction..... May 30, 2007, 12:07 pm
How to remove concrete from vinyl garage door? July 2, 2006, 10:57 am
New concrete floor November 17, 2006, 4:08 pm
Concrete slab for basement floor June 30, 2007, 10:25 pm
How to find if the floor is made of concrete from the external look August 8, 2006, 12:35 pm
Anchor Bolts - Commode To Concrete Floor September 19, 2006, 12:04 pm

Contact Us | Privacy Policy

XML SitemapXML Sitemap