Home Page link

cracks in the slab

Building Construction - Building Construction Industry Discussions. 

Page 2 of 2       << first < 1 2 Bookmark this page:  YahooMyWeb Yahoo!  Google Google  Windows Live Favorites Windows Live  del.icio.us del.icio.us  digg digg  Add to Netscape Netscape
Subject Author Date
cracks in the slab lelson 07-09-2006
If you were  Registered and logged in, you could reply and use other advanced thread options
Posted by Bob on July 10, 2006, 10:16 am

Judanne wrote:
> This is exactly what happened to the slab in my p/s house. The soil had a
> lot of clay in it so there was a lot of movement between winter (wet & clay
> expanded) and summer (dry & clay shrunk). The slab was laid according to
> council regulations with extra cement pourings needed (which meant doubling
> the cost) because the clay went deeper than was first thought (of course!!).

Clay is the best foundation for concrete slabs because the superfine
particles compact into a solid mass. In fact clay is hauled in and used
as a stabilizer over looser soils. *Any* soil will expand & contract
with moisture variations, but clay will do it less. That is why the
old saying is: "the only sure things in this life are death, taxes, and
cracks in concrete".

> There was no long term effect on the p/s performance but tiles laid on the
> cement in the living areas had hairline cracks in them from the seasonal
> movement. The tiles were laid within 2 months of the slab being poured and
> I was told (much later) that in order to avoid the hairline cracks I should
> have waited 12 months to put them down.

Concrete takes a while to shed it's water and cure to size & strength.
In fact the cureing curve of concrete extends upwards to 30 years. So
your waiting for 12 months would have had little effect on hairline
cracks. Those are characteristic of concrete and *cannot* be avoided.
Larger cracks are avoided by wire and rebar in the concrete - it cracks
but doesn't separate into large cracks.

Bob


Posted by Judanne on July 14, 2006, 8:34 pm
Thanks, Bob

Judanne

>
> Judanne wrote:
>> This is exactly what happened to the slab in my p/s house. The soil had
>> a
>> lot of clay in it so there was a lot of movement between winter (wet &
>> clay
>> expanded) and summer (dry & clay shrunk). The slab was laid according to
>> council regulations with extra cement pourings needed (which meant
>> doubling
>> the cost) because the clay went deeper than was first thought (of
>> course!!).
>
> Clay is the best foundation for concrete slabs because the superfine
> particles compact into a solid mass. In fact clay is hauled in and used
> as a stabilizer over looser soils. *Any* soil will expand & contract
> with moisture variations, but clay will do it less. That is why the
> old saying is: "the only sure things in this life are death, taxes, and
> cracks in concrete".
>
>> There was no long term effect on the p/s performance but tiles laid on
>> the
>> cement in the living areas had hairline cracks in them from the seasonal
>> movement. The tiles were laid within 2 months of the slab being poured
>> and
>> I was told (much later) that in order to avoid the hairline cracks I
>> should
>> have waited 12 months to put them down.
>
> Concrete takes a while to shed it's water and cure to size & strength.
> In fact the cureing curve of concrete extends upwards to 30 years. So
> your waiting for 12 months would have had little effect on hairline
> cracks. Those are characteristic of concrete and *cannot* be avoided.
> Larger cracks are avoided by wire and rebar in the concrete - it cracks
> but doesn't separate into large cracks.
>
> Bob
>



Posted by Robert Gammon on July 15, 2006, 7:03 am
Judanne wrote:
> Thanks, Bob
>
> Judanne
>
>
>> Judanne wrote:
>>
>>> This is exactly what happened to the slab in my p/s house. The soil had
>>> a
>>> lot of clay in it so there was a lot of movement between winter (wet &
>>> clay
>>> expanded) and summer (dry & clay shrunk). The slab was laid according to
>>> council regulations with extra cement pourings needed (which meant
>>> doubling
>>> the cost) because the clay went deeper than was first thought (of
>>> course!!).
>>>
>> Clay is the best foundation for concrete slabs because the superfine
>> particles compact into a solid mass. In fact clay is hauled in and used
>> as a stabilizer over looser soils. *Any* soil will expand & contract
>> with moisture variations, but clay will do it less. That is why the
>> old saying is: "the only sure things in this life are death, taxes, and
>> cracks in concrete".
>>
>>
>>> There was no long term effect on the p/s performance but tiles laid on
>>> the
>>> cement in the living areas had hairline cracks in them from the seasonal
>>> movement. The tiles were laid within 2 months of the slab being poured
>>> and
>>> I was told (much later) that in order to avoid the hairline cracks I
>>> should
>>> have waited 12 months to put them down.
>>>
>> Concrete takes a while to shed it's water and cure to size & strength.
>> In fact the cureing curve of concrete extends upwards to 30 years. So
>> your waiting for 12 months would have had little effect on hairline
>> cracks. Those are characteristic of concrete and *cannot* be avoided.
>> Larger cracks are avoided by wire and rebar in the concrete - it cracks
>> but doesn't separate into large cracks.
>>


I waited 10 years to install ceramic tiles on a floating slab (several
inches of SAND under it to isolate it from the gumbo [ultra heavy clay]
soil underneath it), and I still have several tiles with hairline cracks
in them.


Posted by on July 10, 2006, 1:21 pm
You should hire yourself the best structural engineer you can find and
make sure he/she represents your interests. Don't rely on the
builder's or his own expert's explanations, which may be designed to
lull you into a false sense of security until all warranty deadlines
run out.

I don't know about the state you're in but well over half the states
have one version or another of a "right to repair law" now, and
you/your lawyer will need to be familiar with it. It's a builder
protection law and will waste more of your time, but if you have it,
it's not an option, you will have to follow its steps.

Good luck. Both vertical and horizontal displacement are, shall we
say, not good.

lelson@bigfoot.com wrote:
> We're having a house built in a rural mountain area where the
> predominant composition of the soil is decomposed granite and a little
> clay. Our house is a passive solar design and uses a rock floor (about
> 3 feet high, 2" rocks or gravel) over a water barrier. The floor of the
> house is 4" thick reinforced concrete on top of the rock floor. Because
> of concerns about ground water, a French drain was installed around the
> perimeter of the house. In one room of the house, the concrete floor
> shows signs of cracking (about 1/16" cracks with about 1/8" uplifting).
> The design of the rock and floor and been approved by engineers and
> been used many times by this builder with no structural problems. At
> certain times of the year, a hole at one side of the house that is
> deeper than the rock floor seems to have water in it which makes me
> think that the ground water can rise and fall.
>
> The contractor speculates that areas with a little more clay may have
> swollen a bit and caused the uplifting. Does this seem likely? Is there
> a way to control this type of uplifting? I realize it is hard to make
> an assessment without seeing the site. What sort of professional should
> we look for for advice?


Page 2 of 2       << first < 1 2
Similar ThreadsPosted
Eliminating or repairing Drywall cracks January 4, 2007, 7:34 am
How to diagnose for cracks or condensation in 1/2" copper pipe January 19, 2007, 7:36 pm
Garage Slab August 19, 2006, 2:52 am
Dog Kennel Slab September 22, 2007, 10:18 pm
pitch on slab February 13, 2008, 8:11 am
concrete slab June 24, 2008, 8:56 am
Concrete slab question June 29, 2007, 12:32 am
Slab and Stemwall Question September 6, 2006, 2:41 am
Concrete slab for parking a car November 9, 2006, 7:05 am
slab vs basement homes February 27, 2007, 2:29 pm

Contact Us | Privacy Policy

XML SitemapXML Sitemap