Home Page link

Comments welcomed:

HVAC Discussions - Heating, ventilation and air conditioning. 

Page 1 of 3       1 2 3 > last >> Bookmark this page:  YahooMyWeb Yahoo!  Google Google  Windows Live Favorites Windows Live  del.icio.us del.icio.us  digg digg  Add to Netscape Netscape
Subject Author Date
Comments welcomed: olddog 12-23-2008
If you were  Registered and logged in, you could reply and use other advanced thread options
Posted by olddog on December 23, 2008, 11:01 pm
Heating/AC 3 ton 14/15 SEER, 12 EISR

Goodman vs. Lennox vs. Rheem

Bid Installed (Easy in and out):

Goodman (14 Seer): $3682

Lennox (14 Seer): $4485

Rheem (15 Seer): $4634

Natural Gas

1711 sq ft house Austin Central TX, vaulted ceilings

I've checked out installers and they have acceptable BBB ratings.

Installers working under umbrella TX state contractors license

Goodman/Lennox: *Airco* = 21 year HVAC Exp per salesman

Rheem: *Autumn HVAC *Installers* Salesman with 3 years exp. Name of
installer = Earnest questionable as to experience (7 years?)

Rheem installer said he wouldn't do a Lennox install "Lennox circuit boards
bad..." "Goodman cheap".

Signed:

"Homemoaner" (Yea though I walk through the valley of the shadow of death)

olddog


Posted by Don Ocean on December 24, 2008, 1:22 am
olddog wrote:
> Heating/AC 3 ton 14/15 SEER, 12 EISR
>
> Goodman vs. Lennox vs. Rheem
>
> Bid Installed (Easy in and out):
>
> Goodman (14 Seer): $3682
>
> Lennox (14 Seer): $4485
>
> Rheem (15 Seer): $4634
>
> Natural Gas
>
> 1711 sq ft house Austin Central TX, vaulted ceilings
>
> I've checked out installers and they have acceptable BBB ratings.

Better Business Bureau is a Joke.. We all are members... Do you really
think they would diss the very folks that pay BBB's Salaries? Check your
neighbors and install whatever equipment is prevalent and has a comuple
of competing companies. That way, in an emergency parts are readily
available and so is service. I got a Fridgidaire furnace call 34 miles
out Sunday nite at -14ºF and a nasty windchill. Logic board was out..
Where do you get a logic board immediately for a Fridgidaire when the
nearest distributor is 280 miles away? Kerosene Torpedo heater has to
suffice. Stinks like all get out, but the house stays warm until parts
get here.

>
> Installers working under umbrella TX state contractors license
>
> Goodman/Lennox: *Airco* = 21 year HVAC Exp per salesman
>
> Rheem: *Autumn HVAC *Installers* Salesman with 3 years exp. Name of
> installer = Earnest questionable as to experience (7 years?)
>
> Rheem installer said he wouldn't do a Lennox install "Lennox circuit boards
> bad..." "Goodman cheap".
>
> Signed:
>
> "Homemoaner" (Yea though I walk through the valley of the shadow of death)
>
> olddog
>

Posted by Bubba on December 24, 2008, 9:14 am
wrote:

>olddog wrote:
>> Heating/AC 3 ton 14/15 SEER, 12 EISR
>>
>> Goodman vs. Lennox vs. Rheem
>>
>> Bid Installed (Easy in and out):
>>
>> Goodman (14 Seer): $3682
>>
>> Lennox (14 Seer): $4485
>>
>> Rheem (15 Seer): $4634
>>
>> Natural Gas
>>
>> 1711 sq ft house Austin Central TX, vaulted ceilings
>>
>> I've checked out installers and they have acceptable BBB ratings.
>Better Business Bureau is a Joke.. We all are members... Do you really
>think they would diss the very folks that pay BBB's Salaries? Check your
>neighbors and install whatever equipment is prevalent and has a comuple
>of competing companies. That way, in an emergency parts are readily
>available and so is service. I got a Fridgidaire furnace call 34 miles
>out Sunday nite at -14ºF and a nasty windchill. Logic board was out..
>Where do you get a logic board immediately for a Fridgidaire when the
>nearest distributor is 280 miles away? Kerosene Torpedo heater has to
>suffice. Stinks like all get out, but the house stays warm until parts
>get here.
Don,
You might want to try out this board as a stock item.
http://www.climatedoctors.com/items/item.aspx?itemid=429687
Fits a ton of furnaces.
Bubba

>> Installers working under umbrella TX state contractors license
>>
>> Goodman/Lennox: *Airco* = 21 year HVAC Exp per salesman
>>
>> Rheem: *Autumn HVAC *Installers* Salesman with 3 years exp. Name of
>> installer = Earnest questionable as to experience (7 years?)
>>
>> Rheem installer said he wouldn't do a Lennox install "Lennox circuit boards
>> bad..." "Goodman cheap".
>>
>> Signed:
>>
>> "Homemoaner" (Yea though I walk through the valley of the shadow of death)
>>
>> olddog
>>

Posted by Don Ocean on December 25, 2008, 12:39 am
Bubba wrote:
> wrote:
>
>> olddog wrote:
>>> Heating/AC 3 ton 14/15 SEER, 12 EISR
>>> Goodman vs. Lennox vs. Rheem
>>> Bid Installed (Easy in and out):
>>> Goodman (14 Seer): $3682
>>> Lennox (14 Seer): $4485
>>> Rheem (15 Seer): $4634
>>> Natural Gas
>>> 1711 sq ft house Austin Central TX, vaulted ceilings
>>> I've checked out installers and they have acceptable BBB ratings.
>> Better Business Bureau is a Joke.. We all are members... Do you really
>> think they would diss the very folks that pay BBB's Salaries? Check your
>> neighbors and install whatever equipment is prevalent and has a comuple
>> of competing companies. That way, in an emergency parts are readily
>> available and so is service. I got a Fridgidaire furnace call 34 miles
>> out Sunday nite at -14ºF and a nasty windchill. Logic board was out..
>> Where do you get a logic board immediately for a Fridgidaire when the
>> nearest distributor is 280 miles away? Kerosene Torpedo heater has to
>> suffice. Stinks like all get out, but the house stays warm until parts
>> get here.
> Don,
> You might want to try out this board as a stock item.
> http://www.climatedoctors.com/items/item.aspx?itemid=429687
> Fits a ton of furnaces.
> Bubba

Sounds good, but this unit was 2 years old and owner expected Warranty
parts. I am sure he would have settled for paying cash that night
though. These farm boys that decide to be HVAC installers and then
haul ass into the sunset are a real pain in the ass.
>
>>> Installers working under umbrella TX state contractors license
>>> Goodman/Lennox: *Airco* = 21 year HVAC Exp per salesman
>>> Rheem: *Autumn HVAC *Installers* Salesman with 3 years exp. Name of
>>> installer = Earnest questionable as to experience (7 years?)
>>> Rheem installer said he wouldn't do a Lennox install "Lennox circuit boards
>>> bad..." "Goodman cheap".
>>> Signed:
>>> "Homemoaner" (Yea though I walk through the valley of the shadow of death)
>>> olddog

Posted by Stormin Mormon on December 24, 2008, 9:39 am
I'd start by asking your friends and neighbors what they use. I have a
Luxaire (by York) furnace in my trailer. My boss used to install almost
exclusively Rheem Contour furnaces, he liked the complicated thermostat that
communicates with the furnace. The couple times I've worked on Goodman
equipment (formerly called Janitrol) it's been reasonable equipment. Given
these three quotes, and no other information, I'd take the Goodman install.
Less proprietary parts, and easier to work on.

--
Christopher A. Young
Learn more about Jesus
www.lds.org
.


Heating/AC 3 ton 14/15 SEER, 12 EISR

Goodman vs. Lennox vs. Rheem

Bid Installed (Easy in and out):

Goodman (14 Seer): $3682

Lennox (14 Seer): $4485

Rheem (15 Seer): $4634

Natural Gas

1711 sq ft house Austin Central TX, vaulted ceilings

I've checked out installers and they have acceptable BBB ratings.

Installers working under umbrella TX state contractors license

Goodman/Lennox: *Airco* = 21 year HVAC Exp per salesman

Rheem: *Autumn HVAC *Installers* Salesman with 3 years exp. Name of
installer = Earnest questionable as to experience (7 years?)

Rheem installer said he wouldn't do a Lennox install "Lennox circuit boards
bad..." "Goodman cheap".

Signed:

"Homemoaner" (Yea though I walk through the valley of the shadow of death)

olddog



Page 1 of 3       1 2 3 > last >>
Similar ThreadsPosted
Any comments about DC inverter technology? February 27, 2009, 11:16 am

Contact Us | Privacy Policy

XML SitemapXML Sitemap