Home Page link

Lightning fun...

HVAC Discussions - Heating, ventilation and air conditioning. 

Page 1 of 2       1 2 > last >> Bookmark this page:  YahooMyWeb Yahoo!  Google Google  Windows Live Favorites Windows Live  del.icio.us del.icio.us  digg digg  Add to Netscape Netscape
Subject Author Date
Lightning fun... Jake 08-08-2007
If you were  Registered and logged in, you could reply and use other advanced thread options
Posted by Jake on August 8, 2007, 8:50 pm
We've had a rough few days here in Central Indiana.... it's topping 100
most afternoons.

Monday night, we had a fierce lightning storm blow through. As the
regulars here know... I go fix that for my customers.

Roll up early AM Tuesday to a dark plant... 8 mW sub down. The breaker
had opened.

Duke Energy (the Carolina folks that bought out our local outfit,
CIEnergy)have demanded that factories with large loads don't have
"re-close" without an approval from the network people in... well,
wherever they are.

"Re-closing" happens fairly regularly in the real world. Say your City
sub-station takes a lightning hit, or a line drops somewhere... the
primary power source opens up to protect itself... then waits a few
seconds and turns things back on. In this amount of time, a downed line
has usually cleared a local fuse so the breaker says "OK, let's give the
other 40,000 people juice."

So.. back to the real world. I roll up. Dark plant and 400 people
standing around. I dig out the spot and check the "local circuit", a 15
kV line. All looks OK. I tell Duke... on behalf of my customer... to
close the breaker. Linemen from CINERGY were with me and agreed the
"lightning dance" probably tripped the plant... the breaker showed a
"time-out" ground to "B" phase.... that's all.

... Now, we wait 2 and a half hours for somebody, somewhere to decide if
it's OK to "heat it up.". 2 and a half hours.... me, two of our trucks
and SIX people from Duke stood around and shook our heads. We actually
debated closing the damn breaker, anyway.

Funny thing... I'm standing there with one of the Duke sub-station guys
and his phone rings. It's his wife telling him Duke just called and
asked that he come to work... that he was needed exactly where we're
standing....

Geeze... the Duke guys say to me... this has been going on for months.
If the "cluster-fuck" continues, someone could easily get killed. No-one
knows where anyone else is... the linemen use their cell-phones to
communicate because the dispatch is clueless. Systems people.. who work
not more than 15 feet from distribution people... are not talking to one
another. I told Julie when I got home.. this stuff scares me.

Used to be... (before "corporate downsizing") that you'd call the
systems people and say... "Hey, I've gotta take this XXX 69 line down to
re-connect". We'd tag it out, move down the line and rest assured that
EVERYONE down the circuit was safe. I'm not so sure that's the case anymore.

I trust my fellow electricians... whether they work for Duke or anyone
else. I always believed they'd keep me safe.

With this latest problem... I'm not so sure anyone in management cares
whether the guys in the trenches get hurt... or not.

Sorry... consider this a rant.

Jake





Posted by on August 8, 2007, 9:12 pm

>We've had a rough few days here in Central Indiana.... it's topping 100
>most afternoons.
>
>Monday night, we had a fierce lightning storm blow through. As the
>regulars here know... I go fix that for my customers.
>
>Roll up early AM Tuesday to a dark plant... 8 mW sub down. The breaker
>had opened.
>
>Duke Energy (the Carolina folks that bought out our local outfit,
>CIEnergy)have demanded that factories with large loads don't have
>"re-close" without an approval from the network people in... well,
>wherever they are.

        Rachere, NC.

>... Now, we wait 2 and a half hours for somebody, somewhere to decide if
>it's OK to "heat it up.". 2 and a half hours.... me, two of our trucks
>and SIX people from Duke stood around and shook our heads. We actually
>debated closing the damn breaker, anyway.

        You apparently forgot to say 'Hello, how are Yeeeeew ? Might
could yawl plase put the fire to us, rachere ?'

>With this latest problem... I'm not so sure anyone in management cares
>whether the guys in the trenches get hurt... or not.

        Count on it - they don't. That's what they have insurance,
lawyers, and PR departments for.


--
Click here every day to feed an animal that needs you today !!!
http://www.theanimalrescuesite.com/

Paul ( pjm @ pobox . com ) - remove spaces to email me
'Some days, it's just not worth chewing through the restraints.'
'With sufficient thrust, pigs fly just fine.'
HVAC/R program for Palm PDA's
Free demo now available online http://pmilligan.net/palm/

Posted by Geoman on August 10, 2007, 11:30 am

> We've had a rough few days here in Central Indiana.... it's topping 100
> most afternoons.
>
> Monday night, we had a fierce lightning storm blow through. As the
> regulars here know... I go fix that for my customers.
>
> Roll up early AM Tuesday to a dark plant... 8 mW sub down. The breaker had
> opened.
>
> Duke Energy (the Carolina folks that bought out our local outfit,
> CIEnergy)have demanded that factories with large loads don't have
> "re-close" without an approval from the network people in... well,
> wherever they are.
>
> "Re-closing" happens fairly regularly in the real world. Say your City
> sub-station takes a lightning hit, or a line drops somewhere... the
> primary power source opens up to protect itself... then waits a few
> seconds and turns things back on. In this amount of time, a downed line
> has usually cleared a local fuse so the breaker says "OK, let's give the
> other 40,000 people juice."
>
> So.. back to the real world. I roll up. Dark plant and 400 people standing
> around. I dig out the spot and check the "local circuit", a 15 kV line.
> All looks OK. I tell Duke... on behalf of my customer... to close the
> breaker. Linemen from CINERGY were with me and agreed the "lightning
> dance" probably tripped the plant... the breaker showed a "time-out"
> ground to "B" phase.... that's all.
>
> ... Now, we wait 2 and a half hours for somebody, somewhere to decide if
> it's OK to "heat it up.". 2 and a half hours.... me, two of our trucks and
> SIX people from Duke stood around and shook our heads. We actually debated
> closing the damn breaker, anyway.
>
> Funny thing... I'm standing there with one of the Duke sub-station guys
> and his phone rings. It's his wife telling him Duke just called and asked
> that he come to work... that he was needed exactly where we're
> standing....
>
> Geeze... the Duke guys say to me... this has been going on for months. If
> the "cluster-fuck" continues, someone could easily get killed. No-one
> knows where anyone else is... the linemen use their cell-phones to
> communicate because the dispatch is clueless. Systems people.. who work
> not more than 15 feet from distribution people... are not talking to one
> another. I told Julie when I got home.. this stuff scares me.
>
> Used to be... (before "corporate downsizing") that you'd call the systems
> people and say... "Hey, I've gotta take this XXX 69 line down to
> re-connect". We'd tag it out, move down the line and rest assured that
> EVERYONE down the circuit was safe. I'm not so sure that's the case
> anymore.
>
> I trust my fellow electricians... whether they work for Duke or anyone
> else. I always believed they'd keep me safe.
>
> With this latest problem... I'm not so sure anyone in management cares
> whether the guys in the trenches get hurt... or not.
>
> Sorry... consider this a rant.
>
> Jake

Your part around Anderson In. always gets the worse storms! My daughter went
to Anderson U and they always have severe weather!

If you guys are messed up then Ohio Ed/First Energy is too. You can't even
get a live person on the phone until you pressed every number ten times on
the phone pad, THEN they call you back or its always the wrong dept. The
other thing is cut back. I'm told by a lineman friend of mine that the
linemen are VERY VERY Short handed right now, when a storm moves in they
bring up linemen from up to five states and they aren't familiar with the
layouts or the area, which doesn't make for a great safety margin. Heck, we
can't even cut the trees correctly without downing the eastern half of the
USA.

Rich



Posted by Jake on August 10, 2007, 7:07 pm
Geoman wrote:
>> We've had a rough few days here in Central Indiana.... it's topping 100
>> most afternoons.
>>
>> Monday night, we had a fierce lightning storm blow through. As the
>> regulars here know... I go fix that for my customers.
>>
>> Roll up early AM Tuesday to a dark plant... 8 mW sub down. The breaker had
>> opened.
>>
>> Duke Energy (the Carolina folks that bought out our local outfit,
>> CIEnergy)have demanded that factories with large loads don't have
>> "re-close" without an approval from the network people in... well,
>> wherever they are.
>>
>> "Re-closing" happens fairly regularly in the real world. Say your City
>> sub-station takes a lightning hit, or a line drops somewhere... the
>> primary power source opens up to protect itself... then waits a few
>> seconds and turns things back on. In this amount of time, a downed line
>> has usually cleared a local fuse so the breaker says "OK, let's give the
>> other 40,000 people juice."
>>
>> So.. back to the real world. I roll up. Dark plant and 400 people standing
>> around. I dig out the spot and check the "local circuit", a 15 kV line.
>> All looks OK. I tell Duke... on behalf of my customer... to close the
>> breaker. Linemen from CINERGY were with me and agreed the "lightning
>> dance" probably tripped the plant... the breaker showed a "time-out"
>> ground to "B" phase.... that's all.
>>
>> ... Now, we wait 2 and a half hours for somebody, somewhere to decide if
>> it's OK to "heat it up.". 2 and a half hours.... me, two of our trucks and
>> SIX people from Duke stood around and shook our heads. We actually debated
>> closing the damn breaker, anyway.
>>
>> Funny thing... I'm standing there with one of the Duke sub-station guys
>> and his phone rings. It's his wife telling him Duke just called and asked
>> that he come to work... that he was needed exactly where we're
>> standing....
>>
>> Geeze... the Duke guys say to me... this has been going on for months. If
>> the "cluster-fuck" continues, someone could easily get killed. No-one
>> knows where anyone else is... the linemen use their cell-phones to
>> communicate because the dispatch is clueless. Systems people.. who work
>> not more than 15 feet from distribution people... are not talking to one
>> another. I told Julie when I got home.. this stuff scares me.
>>
>> Used to be... (before "corporate downsizing") that you'd call the systems
>> people and say... "Hey, I've gotta take this XXX 69 line down to
>> re-connect". We'd tag it out, move down the line and rest assured that
>> EVERYONE down the circuit was safe. I'm not so sure that's the case
>> anymore.
>>
>> I trust my fellow electricians... whether they work for Duke or anyone
>> else. I always believed they'd keep me safe.
>>
>> With this latest problem... I'm not so sure anyone in management cares
>> whether the guys in the trenches get hurt... or not.
>>
>> Sorry... consider this a rant.
>>
>> Jake
>
> Your part around Anderson In. always gets the worse storms! My daughter went
> to Anderson U and they always have severe weather!
>
> If you guys are messed up then Ohio Ed/First Energy is too. You can't even
> get a live person on the phone until you pressed every number ten times on
> the phone pad, THEN they call you back or its always the wrong dept. The
> other thing is cut back. I'm told by a lineman friend of mine that the
> linemen are VERY VERY Short handed right now, when a storm moves in they
> bring up linemen from up to five states and they aren't familiar with the
> layouts or the area, which doesn't make for a great safety margin. Heck, we
> can't even cut the trees correctly without downing the eastern half of the
> USA.
>
> Rich
>
>

Rich,

We can call that "top secret" number we're sworn not to give anyone
under penalty of death and actually talk to someone at the control
center in Cincy... or wherever they are now.

The problem is... they don't have a clue.

Some folks may not know this, but every single line and every single
transformer hooked to a transmission or distribution center has a number
associated with it. CINergy used to have a decent system where we'd call
Control and say "1001-49, sub 1076, ground T/O fault T/O on X phase,
local cleared to re-connect". If no-one showed up in the database as on
the local line, and the telemetry said there was no fault... they say
"close 1001-49, sub 1076, stay on the line and verify current."

I'd then repeat it to them... EXACTLY. And I'd say "closing 1076,
no-event, 130 all three (or something similar)". Then we'd all go home
and have a beer!

Not anymore... Hell, I think I'm scared of closing another 69 kV circuit
these days for fear of getting someone killed.... or fading Anderson
into darkness.

Jake


Posted by on August 10, 2007, 7:18 pm

>
>We can call that "top secret" number we're sworn not to give anyone
>under penalty of death and actually talk to someone at the control
>center in Cincy... or wherever they are now.

        1-880-EAT-SHIT ?

>
>The problem is... they don't have a clue.
>
>Some folks may not know this, but every single line and every single
>transformer hooked to a transmission or distribution center has a number
>associated with it. CINergy used to have a decent system where we'd call
> Control and say "1001-49, sub 1076, ground T/O fault T/O on X phase,
>local cleared to re-connect".

        There is no X phase. Don't be fucking silly.


> If no-one showed up in the database as on
>the local line, and the telemetry said there was no fault... they say
>"close 1001-49, sub 1076, stay on the line and verify current."
>
>I'd then repeat it to them... EXACTLY. And I'd say "closing 1076,
>no-event, 130 all three (or something similar)". Then we'd all go home
>and have a beer!
>
>Not anymore... Hell, I think I'm scared of closing another 69 kV circuit
>these days for fear of getting someone killed.... or fading Anderson
>into darkness.
>
>Jake

--
Click here every day to feed an animal that needs you today !!!
http://www.theanimalrescuesite.com/

Paul ( pjm @ pobox . com ) - remove spaces to email me
'Some days, it's just not worth chewing through the restraints.'
'With sufficient thrust, pigs fly just fine.'
HVAC/R program for Palm PDA's
Free demo now available online http://pmilligan.net/palm/

Page 1 of 2       1 2 > last >>

Contact Us | Privacy Policy

XML SitemapXML Sitemap