Home Page link

Best Hot Water Heater?

Home Repair - - If it ain't broken, don't fix it. Otherwise look here. 

Page 1 of 2       1 2 > last >> Bookmark this page:  YahooMyWeb Yahoo!  Google Google  Windows Live Favorites Windows Live  del.icio.us del.icio.us  digg digg  Add to Netscape Netscape
Subject Author Date
Best Hot Water Heater? googlemail2003@yahoo.com 05-22-2008
If you were  Registered and logged in, you could reply and use other advanced thread options
Posted by googlemail2003@yahoo.com on May 22, 2008, 10:25 am
We have a 50 gallon heater. It has a 6 year warranty and we've had it
for 6 years. My husband wants to get a new one before we have
problems with this one.

Is changing the water heater every 6 years to be expected? Should we
wait to see when/if this one gives us trouble? Is it like that the
bottom will drop out as the first sign of trouble?

If we replace it, what types are the best. I don't want to do this
every 6 years. According to my plumber getting a heater with a 10
year warranty only means they cover the cost if something happens, it
doesn't mean nothing will go wrong in 10 years.

Aren't there heaters that circulate the water periodically to reduce
mineral buildup?


Posted by Joseph Meehan on May 22, 2008, 10:43 am
The life of a water heater is dependent on a number of factors.

A big one is the local water. Some water while it may be safe, and may
taste fine and be soft, it may not be nice to your water heater. Check with
neighbors and see what experience they are having. A good way of
determining if it is time is if you live in a development where all the
homes were built about the same time. When you start seeing old heaters
waiting to be picked up, it is time to replace yours.

Your plumber is right as far as it goes. It also does not mean nothing
will go wrong in one year. Generally I have heard that there is no
difference in a 6 year and a 10 year water heater other than the warranty.
I don't know if that is true or not.

If your heater is located somewhere that a leak would be costly (those
other cost are not likely covered by the heater warranty) then it might be a
good idea to change it out. On the other hand if it is in an area where a
small leak would cause minimal damage, or if it has a safety catch under it
where the water from a minor leak will be drained away, it is not likely you
are going to have a problem. Very few water heaters leak other than
starting with a slow leak.

When you do replace it make sure you get a safety catch (like a large
shallow pan) under it and ideally have a drain from that pan to a house
drain. Also have an alarm added to alert you if there is a leak.

OK I did not really answer your question did I? The real answer
depends on your and your husbands comfort level. If he is not going to be
comfortable with putting off the replacement, get it replaced and keep him
happy. Hopefully he will do the same when the shoe is on the other foot.
It is all part of life and love. Just think how happy he will be with a
longer lasting water heater with an alarm and a safety catch. Consider it
an early Birthday present for him.

> We have a 50 gallon heater. It has a 6 year warranty and we've had it
> for 6 years. My husband wants to get a new one before we have
> problems with this one.
>
> Is changing the water heater every 6 years to be expected? Should we
> wait to see when/if this one gives us trouble? Is it like that the
> bottom will drop out as the first sign of trouble?
>
> If we replace it, what types are the best. I don't want to do this
> every 6 years. According to my plumber getting a heater with a 10
> year warranty only means they cover the cost if something happens, it
> doesn't mean nothing will go wrong in 10 years.
>
> Aren't there heaters that circulate the water periodically to reduce
> mineral buildup?
>


--
Joseph Meehan

Dia 's Muire duit




Posted by ransley on May 22, 2008, 11:26 am
On May 22, 9:25=A0am, "googlemail2...@yahoo.com"
> We have a 50 gallon heater. =A0It has a 6 year warranty and we've had it
> for 6 years. =A0My husband wants to get a new one before we have
> problems with this one.
>
> Is changing the water heater every 6 years to be expected? =A0Should we
> wait to see when/if this one gives us trouble? =A0Is it like that the
> bottom will drop out as the first sign of trouble?
>
> If we replace it, what types are the best. =A0I don't want to do this
> every 6 years. =A0According to my plumber getting a heater with a 10
> year warranty only means they cover the cost if something happens, it
> doesn't mean nothing will go wrong in 10 years.
>
> Aren't there heaters that circulate the water periodically to reduce
> mineral buildup?

In my area they last longer 15-20 years Chicago water, but it depends
on the brand, I had a commercial AO Smith last maybe 22-25 years. If
you shop, shop EF- energy factor and quality like AO Smith. Tankless
coil WH are designed for 30 years. Your neighbors should be able to
tell you how your water affects their heaters life. If the basement is
finished and a leak would cause damage a pan under the tank with a
hose going to a drain is good as are automatic valves with a water
sensor on the floor, that sense a leak and turn off water before major
damage happens.

Posted by on May 22, 2008, 12:41 pm
> On May 22, 9:25=A0am, "googlemail2...@yahoo.com"
>
>
>
>
>
> > We have a 50 gallon heater. =A0It has a 6 year warranty and we've had it=

> > for 6 years. =A0My husband wants to get a new one before we have
> > problems with this one.
>
> > Is changing the water heater every 6 years to be expected? =A0Should we
> > wait to see when/if this one gives us trouble? =A0Is it like that the
> > bottom will drop out as the first sign of trouble?
>
> > If we replace it, what types are the best. =A0I don't want to do this
> > every 6 years. =A0According to my plumber getting a heater with a 10
> > year warranty only means they cover the cost if something happens, it
> > doesn't mean nothing will go wrong in 10 years.
>
> > Aren't there heaters that circulate the water periodically to reduce
> > mineral buildup?
>
> In my area they last longer 15-20 years Chicago water, but it depends
> on the brand, I had a commercial AO Smith last maybe 22-25 years. If
> you shop, shop EF- energy factor and quality like AO Smith. Tankless
> coil WH are designed for 30 years. Your neighbors should be able to
> tell you how your water affects their heaters life. If the basement is
> finished and a leak would cause damage a pan under the tank with a
> hose going to a drain is good as are automatic valves with a water
> sensor on the floor, that sense a leak and turn off water before major
> damage happens.- Hide quoted text -
>
> - Show quoted text -

Also, there is generally a big difference between the life of a gas
heater and an electric one. Typical gas ones go about 13 years,
electric 20. But that can vary greatly depending on the local
water. Neighbors experiences can be one guide. Also, water
heaters have a sacraficial anode that is there to erode over time
instead of the tank. You can unscrew it and check it every few
years. That will give some measure of how the water is affecting the
tank. Also, if the anode is shot, you can replace it and extend the
protection. The anode screws into the top of the tank and has a hex
head, I think it's 1 1/8" socket.

As already pointed out, a lot depends on where it's located, in terms
of how long you want to push the life. If it's in a spot where a
leak won't be a big disaster, it's one thing. If it's somewhere that
doesn't have a good drain, finished basement, etc, then that would
argue for earlier replacement.

Posted by Pipedown on May 22, 2008, 1:28 pm
Since your six year WH lasted 6 years its a safe guess that you have average
water (not too anything). In my experience, water heaters often do last
approximately as long as their warranties or a little longer (manufacturers
have had over 100 years to fine tune this). If you replace the anode rod
about 1/2 way throrough the warrany or once every 3-4 years, you should be
able to extend the working life of the tank considerably. When the new tank
is installed, remove the anode rod and reinstall it with teflon tape.
Without that they can be very difficult to remove after several years and
nearly impossible near the end of the warranty term.

The basic difference between a 6 and 10 year tank is the tank wall thickness
and diameter of anode rod. The extra cost is mainly in the warranty since
the extra materials are not all that much.



> We have a 50 gallon heater. It has a 6 year warranty and we've had it
> for 6 years. My husband wants to get a new one before we have
> problems with this one.
>
> Is changing the water heater every 6 years to be expected? Should we
> wait to see when/if this one gives us trouble? Is it like that the
> bottom will drop out as the first sign of trouble?
>
> If we replace it, what types are the best. I don't want to do this
> every 6 years. According to my plumber getting a heater with a 10
> year warranty only means they cover the cost if something happens, it
> doesn't mean nothing will go wrong in 10 years.
>
> Aren't there heaters that circulate the water periodically to reduce
> mineral buildup?
>



Page 1 of 2       1 2 > last >>
Similar ThreadsPosted
tankless water heater vs. small water heater. October 14, 2006, 10:36 pm
hot water heater leak and tankless water heater? October 28, 2006, 6:42 pm
Hot water heater is really a luke warm heater May 15, 2007, 1:57 pm
oil hot water heater--WANT TO CONVERT to pool heater January 4, 2008, 7:32 pm
Copper tube to cold water inlet on Water Heater is Warm/Hot April 3, 2007, 4:09 pm
Electric Water Heater Grounded to Copper Water Pipes? October 29, 2005, 6:04 pm
hot water heater Question? Water in the thermostat access panel October 5, 2006, 2:50 pm
hot water heater Question? Water in the thermostat access panel October 5, 2006, 3:11 pm
Re: Hot water hammer, slow flow after draining water heater. March 21, 2007, 5:36 pm
Smelly water from indirect-fired water heater June 5, 2006, 4:44 pm

Contact Us | Privacy Policy

XML SitemapXML Sitemap