Home Page link

Home Addition or Detacted Garage?????????

Home Repair - - If it ain't broken, don't fix it. Otherwise look here. 

Page 1 of 4       1 2 3 > last >> Bookmark this page:  YahooMyWeb Yahoo!  Google Google  Windows Live Favorites Windows Live  del.icio.us del.icio.us  digg digg  Add to Netscape Netscape
Subject Author Date
Home Addition or Detacted Garage????????? infiniteMPG 06-10-2008
If you were  Registered and logged in, you could reply and use other advanced thread options
Posted by infiniteMPG on June 10, 2008, 4:18 pm
We are looking at expanding our living space in our home here in west
central Florida and we are faced with two main options.... adding on
to our home following the roof line and construction of the house, or
closing in the two car garage, making it living space and adding a
detacted garage. We're not sure of the advantages either way so we
thought we'd pop it out here for the experts to chime in :O)

The house is basically a simple gable roof line runnin parallel with
the road with an "L shape where the small leg of the "L" is the two
car garage facing forward on the right side of the house. We were
considering extending the gable towards the right, past the garage and
make the new rooms in this area. This would just continue the main
gable roof further and since the garage roof intersects the front of
the existing gable it shouldn't impact the garage area at all. This
also leaves the master bathroom connections where they are so there
should be no plumbing impact.

The second option is to block in the front garage door and turn the
garage into additional living space. Then build a detacted garage to
the right of the existing garage and since it's detacted, wouldn't
impact the central house. One consideration here is the existing
garage floor is dropped lower then the rest of the house (about 6")
and we're conserned if we just block in the front garage door that
there might be a moisture issue in the garage (we're thinking the
walls would have to be sealed good). Plus the garage walls are block
so there isn't really any insullation in there.

We're a little leaning towards the extension of the main house but we
figured we're not experts so thought there might be something we're
overlooking.

Thanks for your assistance!

Posted by infiniteMPG on June 10, 2008, 4:24 pm
Maybe I could start off on the right/write foot by learning how to
spell detatched.... :O/

hehehehehe

Posted by on June 10, 2008, 5:12 pm
> We are looking at expanding our living space in our home here in west
> central Florida and we are faced with two main options.... adding on
> to our home following the roof line and construction of the house, or
> closing in the two car garage, making it living space and adding a
> detacted garage. =A0We're not sure of the advantages either way so we
> thought we'd pop it out here for the experts to chime in =A0:O)
>
> The house is basically a simple gable roof line runnin parallel with
> the road with an "L shape where the small leg of the "L" is the two
> car garage facing forward on the right side of the house. =A0We were
> considering extending the gable towards the right, past the garage and
> make the new rooms in this area. =A0This would just continue the main
> gable roof further and since the garage roof intersects the front of
> the existing gable it shouldn't impact the garage area at all. =A0This
> also leaves the master bathroom connections where they are so there
> should be no plumbing impact.
>
> The second option is to block in the front garage door and turn the
> garage into additional living space. =A0Then build a detacted garage to
> the right of the existing garage and since it's detacted, wouldn't
> impact the central house. =A0One consideration here is the existing
> garage floor is dropped lower then the rest of the house (about 6")
> and we're conserned if we just block in the front garage door that
> there might be a moisture issue in the garage (we're thinking the
> walls would have to be sealed good). =A0Plus the garage walls are block
> so there isn't really any insullation in there.
>
> We're a little leaning towards the extension of the main house but we
> figured we're not experts so thought there might be something we're
> overlooking.
>
> Thanks for your assistance!



This is really impossible to answer without actually seeing it. And
even then, it can take someone with good visualization and knowledge
to give you the right answer. I'd engagne an architect.

One thing I would say, and that's most people prefer garages to be
attached. It allows you to go from the living space to the car
without regard to the outside weather. Probably less of a factor in
FL, than NY, but still if there is a downpour, you can avoid it and it
makes carrrying in groceries, etc easier.

Posted by John Grabowski on June 10, 2008, 6:35 pm

> We are looking at expanding our living space in our home here in west
> central Florida and we are faced with two main options.... adding on
> to our home following the roof line and construction of the house, or
> closing in the two car garage, making it living space and adding a
> detacted garage. We're not sure of the advantages either way so we
> thought we'd pop it out here for the experts to chime in :O)
>
> The house is basically a simple gable roof line runnin parallel with
> the road with an "L shape where the small leg of the "L" is the two
> car garage facing forward on the right side of the house. We were
> considering extending the gable towards the right, past the garage and
> make the new rooms in this area. This would just continue the main
> gable roof further and since the garage roof intersects the front of
> the existing gable it shouldn't impact the garage area at all. This
> also leaves the master bathroom connections where they are so there
> should be no plumbing impact.
>
> The second option is to block in the front garage door and turn the
> garage into additional living space. Then build a detacted garage to
> the right of the existing garage and since it's detacted, wouldn't
> impact the central house. One consideration here is the existing
> garage floor is dropped lower then the rest of the house (about 6")
> and we're conserned if we just block in the front garage door that
> there might be a moisture issue in the garage (we're thinking the
> walls would have to be sealed good). Plus the garage walls are block
> so there isn't really any insullation in there.
>
> We're a little leaning towards the extension of the main house but we
> figured we're not experts so thought there might be something we're
> overlooking.


How about posting some pictures of the existing house so we can get a better
idea of what you're talking about. I've seen several attached garages that
have been converted to living space and I didn't like the way they turned
out. Maybe it was because they were done on a low budget, but it was always
obvious from the outside that there was a garage at one time. Maybe they
were done with the intention of having the option to convert back to a
garage.

Check out what others have done in your neighborhood. Check out the ones
that look like they have been added on to against the ones that don't look
like an addition has been made.


Posted by RobertPatrick on June 10, 2008, 9:53 pm

>
> ..
>> We are looking at expanding our living space in our home here in west
>> central Florida and we are faced with two main options.... adding on
>> to our home following the roof line and construction of the house, or
>> closing in the two car garage, making it living space and adding a
>> detacted garage. We're not sure of the advantages either way so we
>> thought we'd pop it out here for the experts to chime in :O)
>>
>> The house is basically a simple gable roof line runnin parallel with
>> the road with an "L shape where the small leg of the "L" is the two
>> car garage facing forward on the right side of the house. We were
>> considering extending the gable towards the right, past the garage
>> and make the new rooms in this area. This would just continue the
>> main gable roof further and since the garage roof intersects the
>> front of the existing gable it shouldn't impact the garage area at
>> all. This also leaves the master bathroom connections where they are
>> so there should be no plumbing impact.
>>
>> The second option is to block in the front garage door and turn the
>> garage into additional living space. Then build a detacted garage to
>> the right of the existing garage and since it's detacted, wouldn't
>> impact the central house. One consideration here is the existing
>> garage floor is dropped lower then the rest of the house (about 6")
>> and we're conserned if we just block in the front garage door that
>> there might be a moisture issue in the garage (we're thinking the
>> walls would have to be sealed good). Plus the garage walls are block
>> so there isn't really any insullation in there.
>>
>> We're a little leaning towards the extension of the main house but we
>> figured we're not experts so thought there might be something we're
>> overlooking.
>
>
> How about posting some pictures of the existing house so we can get a
> better idea of what you're talking about. I've seen several attached
> garages that have been converted to living space and I didn't like the
> way they turned out. Maybe it was because they were done on a low
> budget, but it was always obvious from the outside that there was a
> garage at one time. Maybe they were done with the intention of having
> the option to convert back to a garage.
>
> Check out what others have done in your neighborhood. Check out the
> ones that look like they have been added on to against the ones that
> don't look like an addition has been made.
>
>

Adding on and you should marry the roof lines. Don't know how expensive
that would be.

Converted garages tend to look like converted garages.

A detached garage isn't wanted by most people.

You have a one story or two? A neighbor built a partial 2nd floor. It
looks good. It looks like a split level.(if you like split levels). But
for the original house what they did looks good.

Page 1 of 4       1 2 3 > last >>
Similar ThreadsPosted
home addition Q September 1, 2007, 7:46 pm
help on sunroom addition July 11, 2005, 5:37 pm
Attaching an addition March 14, 2006, 3:52 pm
stucco addition August 6, 2006, 6:34 pm
bathroom addition September 30, 2007, 10:25 pm
Addition to a monolithic slab July 26, 2006, 3:11 pm
Ventilation ideas for under new addition September 24, 2006, 1:58 pm
Room Addition, how hard? July 22, 2007, 7:40 am
plumbing diagram for house addition.... August 25, 2005, 5:52 am
Heating and Cooling an Addition - Any Suggestions November 9, 2005, 10:57 am

Contact Us | Privacy Policy

XML SitemapXML Sitemap