Home Page link

Is the NEW Treated Wood any good?

Home Repair - - If it ain't broken, don't fix it. Otherwise look here. 

Page 1 of 2       1 2 > last >> Bookmark this page:  YahooMyWeb Yahoo!  Google Google  Windows Live Favorites Windows Live  del.icio.us del.icio.us  digg digg  Add to Netscape Netscape
Subject Author Date
Is the NEW Treated Wood any good? homeowner2098801 07-24-2007
If you were  Registered and logged in, you could reply and use other advanced thread options
Posted by on July 24, 2007, 10:29 am
Now that they have banned the Arsenic treatment for lumber, I am
wondering if this new treated wood is any good? The stuff barely even
looks treated. I do favor eliminating toxic chemicals from our lives,
I am not going to pay for treated lumber that will be rotted in a few
years and from the looks of this new stuff, I fear it will rot as fast
as untreated lumber. I just discovered this new stuff, and I refused
to buy it. I was lucky to find a small rural lumber yard that had a
large stock of the older arsenic treated wood on hand, and even though
it cost more, I bought it. At least I know it will last for years
like all the older treated lumber did. Somehow I have a feeling this
new (so called) treated lumber is little more than plain lumber
sprayed with a green colored water. I dont want it !



Posted by Tony Hwang on July 24, 2007, 11:31 am
homeowner2098801@usa.com wrote:
> Now that they have banned the Arsenic treatment for lumber, I am
> wondering if this new treated wood is any good? The stuff barely even
> looks treated. I do favor eliminating toxic chemicals from our lives,
> I am not going to pay for treated lumber that will be rotted in a few
> years and from the looks of this new stuff, I fear it will rot as fast
> as untreated lumber. I just discovered this new stuff, and I refused
> to buy it. I was lucky to find a small rural lumber yard that had a
> large stock of the older arsenic treated wood on hand, and even though
> it cost more, I bought it. At least I know it will last for years
> like all the older treated lumber did. Somehow I have a feeling this
> new (so called) treated lumber is little more than plain lumber
> sprayed with a green colored water. I dont want it !
>
>
Hmmm,
Very interesting. You do favor eliminating toxic chemicals and yet buy
that lumber treated with arsenic. I never knew arsenic is not toxic,
LOL! I built a cabin on a newly treated wood pile, after 10 years it
still stands. Whatever that green stuff is injected into wood.

Posted by EXT on July 24, 2007, 12:06 pm
My experience is that the treatment only penetrates a small distance into
the wood, everywhere from 1/4 to a couple of inches depending on the wood. I
have seen pressure treated wood develop a crack in the surface that exposes
the untreated portion allowing water and fungus to enter and the wood to rot
from the inside so that it is like a tree that looks sound but is hollow in
the center.

> homeowner2098801@usa.com wrote:
>> Now that they have banned the Arsenic treatment for lumber, I am
>> wondering if this new treated wood is any good? The stuff barely even
>> looks treated. I do favor eliminating toxic chemicals from our lives,
>> I am not going to pay for treated lumber that will be rotted in a few
>> years and from the looks of this new stuff, I fear it will rot as fast
>> as untreated lumber. I just discovered this new stuff, and I refused
>> to buy it. I was lucky to find a small rural lumber yard that had a
>> large stock of the older arsenic treated wood on hand, and even though
>> it cost more, I bought it. At least I know it will last for years
>> like all the older treated lumber did. Somehow I have a feeling this
>> new (so called) treated lumber is little more than plain lumber
>> sprayed with a green colored water. I dont want it !
>>
>>
> Hmmm,
> Very interesting. You do favor eliminating toxic chemicals and yet buy
> that lumber treated with arsenic. I never knew arsenic is not toxic, LOL!
> I built a cabin on a newly treated wood pile, after 10 years it still
> stands. Whatever that green stuff is injected into wood.



Posted by jmagerl on July 24, 2007, 1:12 pm
Thats why you have to look for the "ground contact" rating. I can't
believe they sell pressure treated landscaping timbers that are not rated
for ground contact. Yet people buy em (pressure treated is pressure treated,
right?) thinking they are getting a bargain and they rot out in 5 years
(the timbers, not the people).

The local big box store had timbers on sale (rated for ground contact in the
ad). WHen I got to the store I could not find a single sale timber that had
the ground contact rating printed on it. YEt the more expensive timber (next
pile over) had the ground contact rating on every timber. I bypassed the
sale.

This goes both for the old arsenixc ones and the AC-3 ones.

> My experience is that the treatment only penetrates a small distance into
> the wood, everywhere from 1/4 to a couple of inches depending on the wood.
> I have seen pressure treated wood develop a crack in the surface that
> exposes the untreated portion allowing water and fungus to enter and the
> wood to rot from the inside so that it is like a tree that looks sound but
> is hollow in the center.
>
>> homeowner2098801@usa.com wrote:
>>> Now that they have banned the Arsenic treatment for lumber, I am
>>> wondering if this new treated wood is any good? The stuff barely even
>>> looks treated. I do favor eliminating toxic chemicals from our lives,
>>> I am not going to pay for treated lumber that will be rotted in a few
>>> years and from the looks of this new stuff, I fear it will rot as fast
>>> as untreated lumber. I just discovered this new stuff, and I refused
>>> to buy it. I was lucky to find a small rural lumber yard that had a
>>> large stock of the older arsenic treated wood on hand, and even though
>>> it cost more, I bought it. At least I know it will last for years
>>> like all the older treated lumber did. Somehow I have a feeling this
>>> new (so called) treated lumber is little more than plain lumber
>>> sprayed with a green colored water. I dont want it !
>>>
>>>
>> Hmmm,
>> Very interesting. You do favor eliminating toxic chemicals and yet buy
>> that lumber treated with arsenic. I never knew arsenic is not toxic, LOL!
>> I built a cabin on a newly treated wood pile, after 10 years it still
>> stands. Whatever that green stuff is injected into wood.
>
>



Posted by HeyBub on July 24, 2007, 1:10 pm
Tony Hwang wrote:
>>
>>
> Hmmm,
> Very interesting. You do favor eliminating toxic chemicals and yet buy
> that lumber treated with arsenic. I never knew arsenic is not toxic,
> LOL! I built a cabin on a newly treated wood pile, after 10 years it
> still stands. Whatever that green stuff is injected into wood.

Arsenic, per se, is not toxic - it's the concentration that counts.

Arsenic just becomes toxic at a lower concentration than, say, Kellogg's
Frosted Flakes.



Page 1 of 2       1 2 > last >>
Similar ThreadsPosted
Pressure treated wood May 9, 2006, 10:11 pm
treated wood on sills November 23, 2006, 11:42 am
How can I tell if old wood is pressure treated? January 28, 2007, 11:25 am
Painting Pressure Treated Wood July 21, 2008, 8:32 pm
Burning Pressure Treated Wood October 17, 2005, 8:10 pm
Pressure-treated wood ratings November 4, 2005, 6:38 pm
Pressure Treated Wood & Aluminum November 15, 2005, 4:35 pm
Dark pressure treated wood March 22, 2006, 9:54 am
Painting Pressure Treated Wood ? May 31, 2006, 7:33 am
warping pressure treated wood August 6, 2006, 10:37 am

Contact Us | Privacy Policy

XML SitemapXML Sitemap