Home Page link

Old house, Ceiling Light Fixture Died, No Change After New Switch

Home Repair - - If it ain't broken, don't fix it. Otherwise look here. 

Bookmark this page:  YahooMyWeb Yahoo!  Google Google  Windows Live Favorites Windows Live  del.icio.us del.icio.us  digg digg  Add to Netscape Netscape
Subject Author Date
Old house, Ceiling Light Fixture Died, No Change After New Switch ASE 02-06-2005
If you were  Registered and logged in, you could reply and use other advanced thread options
Posted by ASE on February 6, 2005, 12:53 pm


Ceiling light fixture was blinking in and out. Replaced the switch
(single pole, no outlet or anything else in box). Now nothing at all.
Old house, mostly old wiring (knob & tube). $2.00 little voltage
tester, the kind with two prongs and little christmas tree bulb, shows
no juice at switch (touch ends to the exposed wire ends) or at the
fixture (again, touch ends of tester to exposed house wire in box).
Have checked and turned off and on circuit breaker (upgraded panel),
and no problems with anything else on that circuit. Do I need to try a
better tester, or is everything fried somewhere in the line, leaving
the choice of no more fixture or ripping apart plaster in old
house(cha-ching cough cough)?



Posted by Joseph Meehan on February 6, 2005, 9:12 pm


ASE wrote:
> Ceiling light fixture was blinking in and out. Replaced the switch
> (single pole, no outlet or anything else in box). Now nothing at all.
> Old house, mostly old wiring (knob & tube). $2.00 little voltage
> tester, the kind with two prongs and little christmas tree bulb, shows
> no juice at switch (touch ends to the exposed wire ends) or at the
> fixture (again, touch ends of tester to exposed house wire in box).
> Have checked and turned off and on circuit breaker (upgraded panel),
> and no problems with anything else on that circuit. Do I need to try
> a better tester, or is everything fried somewhere in the line, leaving
> the choice of no more fixture or ripping apart plaster in old
> house(cha-ching cough cough)?

There are many possible issues. I am going to suggest that from the
information you have provided, you are not really ready to go about checking
for this kind of problem.

Are you familiar with the various ways a light and switch may be wired?
Have you tested the wires in a way that would account for all those ways?

I suggest that you may want to start by buying a good book at the DIY
store or book store and read the section on home wiring. Learn it will
before you start working on this project. Old homes can have many surprises
in the wring. Someone who does not really understand what is going on may
see something that may look OK but it may be a dangerous situation unknown
to them.

You may want to call in a professional.

I am sorry, but from the information you have provided I can't offer
specific advice on how to proceed safely in this kind of forum.

--
Joseph Meehan

26 + 6 = 1 It's Irish Math




Posted by ASE on February 6, 2005, 7:01 pm


Thanks, I should have made it clear that if this involves anything more
than changing the switch or perhap a simple repair to the fixture
itself I ain't touching it. That's why I put in the cha-ching, for
having to pay someone to do major work involving ripping out plaster.
I'm just trying to do a minimal amount of diagnostics myself.

The real point of my post is, can I put any stock in my minimal wire
testing? Does using the cheapie tester the way I did indicate there is
no juice at either the switch or the fixture? And if that's the case,
is the only option hiring someone who can try to find a problem
somewhere in the wiring behind the walls?

Joseph Meehan wrote:
> ASE wrote:
> > Ceiling light fixture was blinking in and out. Replaced the switch
> > (single pole, no outlet or anything else in box). Now nothing at
all.
> > Old house, mostly old wiring (knob & tube). $2.00 little voltage
> > tester, the kind with two prongs and little christmas tree bulb,
shows
> > no juice at switch (touch ends to the exposed wire ends) or at the
> > fixture (again, touch ends of tester to exposed house wire in box).
> > Have checked and turned off and on circuit breaker (upgraded
panel),
> > and no problems with anything else on that circuit. Do I need to
try
> > a better tester, or is everything fried somewhere in the line,
leaving
> > the choice of no more fixture or ripping apart plaster in old
> > house(cha-ching cough cough)?
>
> There are many possible issues. I am going to suggest that from
the
> information you have provided, you are not really ready to go about
checking
> for this kind of problem.
>
> Are you familiar with the various ways a light and switch may be
wired?
> Have you tested the wires in a way that would account for all those
ways?
>
> I suggest that you may want to start by buying a good book at the
DIY
> store or book store and read the section on home wiring. Learn it
will
> before you start working on this project. Old homes can have many
surprises
> in the wring. Someone who does not really understand what is going
on may
> see something that may look OK but it may be a dangerous situation
unknown
> to them.
>
> You may want to call in a professional.
>
> I am sorry, but from the information you have provided I can't
offer
> specific advice on how to proceed safely in this kind of forum.
>
> --
> Joseph Meehan
>
> 26 + 6 = 1 It's Irish Math



Posted by Joseph Meehan on February 7, 2005, 4:57 am


ASE wrote:
> Thanks, I should have made it clear that if this involves anything
> more than changing the switch or perhap a simple repair to the fixture
> itself I ain't touching it. That's why I put in the cha-ching, for
> having to pay someone to do major work involving ripping out plaster.
> I'm just trying to do a minimal amount of diagnostics myself.
>
> The real point of my post is, can I put any stock in my minimal wire
> testing? Does using the cheapie tester the way I did indicate there
> is no juice at either the switch or the fixture? And if that's the
> case, is the only option hiring someone who can try to find a problem
> somewhere in the wiring behind the walls?

The cheap tester is not at fault. The problem is there are far too many
different possible way it could be wired to allow me to provide
comprehensive instructions that would cover the possible code compliant and
code non-compliant possibilities. Sort of that, I would feel like I was
encouraging someone to try something that could get them injured or even
killed. I had a hold home once. It originally was a log cabin, then brick,
gas lighting added sometime along the way and at least three different
version of electric wiring. I ended up totally rewiring it over several
years. It had may non-compliant issues and many could have been dangerous
to anyone doing testing. It almost got me once when I turned pulled fuses
until I got that light to go out, while working on it I discovered that I
did not get the right fuse, the light had just gone out while I was pulling
another fuse.

>
> Joseph Meehan wrote:
>> ASE wrote:
>>> Ceiling light fixture was blinking in and out. Replaced the switch
>>> (single pole, no outlet or anything else in box). Now nothing at
>>> all. Old house, mostly old wiring (knob & tube). $2.00 little
>>> voltage tester, the kind with two prongs and little christmas tree
>>> bulb, shows no juice at switch (touch ends to the exposed wire
>>> ends) or at the fixture (again, touch ends of tester to exposed
>>> house wire in box). Have checked and turned off and on circuit
>>> breaker (upgraded panel), and no problems with anything else on
>>> that circuit. Do I need to try a better tester, or is everything
>>> fried somewhere in the line, leaving the choice of no more fixture
>>> or ripping apart plaster in old house(cha-ching cough cough)?
>>
>> There are many possible issues. I am going to suggest that from
>> the information you have provided, you are not really ready to go
>> about checking for this kind of problem.
>>
>> Are you familiar with the various ways a light and switch may be
>> wired? Have you tested the wires in a way that would account for all
>> those ways?
>>
>> I suggest that you may want to start by buying a good book at
>> the DIY store or book store and read the section on home wiring.
>> Learn it will before you start working on this project. Old homes
>> can have many surprises in the wring. Someone who does not really
>> understand what is going on may see something that may look OK but
>> it may be a dangerous situation unknown to them.
>>
>> You may want to call in a professional.
>>
>> I am sorry, but from the information you have provided I can't
>> offer specific advice on how to proceed safely in this kind of forum.
>>
>> --
>> Joseph Meehan
>>
>> 26 + 6 = 1 It's Irish Math

--
Joseph Meehan

26 + 6 = 1 It's Irish Math




Similar ThreadsPosted
One socket on ceiling fixture died April 9, 2007, 7:22 pm
voltage at ceiling fixture with switch off August 17, 2005, 1:29 am
Wiring a switch for a light fixture April 23, 2007, 11:35 am
Light Switch & Fixture Problem January 25, 2008, 1:42 am
Installing Ceiling Light Fixture April 8, 2006, 7:09 pm
Installing a ceiling fan in a light fixture August 10, 2006, 12:31 pm
wiring a light fixture to an exiting 3 way switch February 15, 2006, 12:54 pm
1volt detected at light fixture when switch off? July 28, 2006, 2:00 pm
Adding a light fixture from an existing switch ? May 8, 2007, 11:08 pm
Three bulb ceiling light fixture question November 17, 2005, 1:03 pm

Contact Us | Privacy Policy

XML SitemapXML Sitemap