Home Page link

Re: damage from blown transformer?

Home Repair - - If it ain't broken, don't fix it. Otherwise look here. 

Bookmark this page:  YahooMyWeb Yahoo!  Google Google  Windows Live Favorites Windows Live  del.icio.us del.icio.us  digg digg  Add to Netscape Netscape
Subject Author Date
Re: damage from blown transformer? Bob F 05-13-2008
If you were  Registered and logged in, you could reply and use other advanced thread options
Posted by Bob F on May 13, 2008, 1:26 am

>
>>>> I considered small claims suit but lawyer advised not to as they always get
>>> away with the "act of God" defense.
>>
>> I've also heard of amature "landscapers" dropping trees across power lines
>> and being held responsible for hundreds of electronic devices in their
>> neighborhood damaged by the resulting surge.
>>
>>
> I had a power transformer blow during a storm and was told it was "an act of
> God" and the home owners insurance would have to take care of it. There is
> nothing with in reason a power comapny could do to prevent that kind of
> damage.
>
> Much differant than when someone cuts a tree over the power lines.

During a storm may be different than this case. (No storm mentioned)



PexSupply PEX Tools 468x60
Posted by Frank on May 13, 2008, 4:18 pm
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
> >>>> I considered small claims suit but lawyer advised not to as they alwa=
ys get
> >>> away with the "act of God" defense.
>
> >> I've also heard of amature "landscapers" dropping trees across power li=
nes
> >> and being held responsible for hundreds of electronic devices in their
> >> neighborhood damaged by the resulting surge.
>
> > I had a power transformer blow during a storm and was told it was "an ac=
t of
> > God" and the home owners insurance would have to take care of it. =A0The=
re is
> > nothing with in reason a =A0power comapny could do to prevent that kind =
of
> > damage.
>
> > Much differant than when someone cuts a tree over the power lines.
>
> During a storm may be different than this case. (No storm mentioned)- Hide=
quoted text -
>
> - Show quoted text -

Homeowners insurance will pay but when working off a $500 deductible
with a $150 microwave oven and $100 worth of surge protectors, it was
not even considered. That year we had 11 power outages with average
of about one day each.

Delmarva Power admitted that they had saved $3 million that year by
cutting back in tree trimming. Me and all my neighbors now have
backup generators.

My cumulative damages were about $600 so insurance was not worth
considering.
My brother had a lightening strike on light pole outside his house
that took out all his electronic equipment so insurance paid.

Posted by N8N on May 13, 2008, 4:29 pm
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
> > >>>> I considered small claims suit but lawyer advised not to as they al=
ways get
> > >>> away with the "act of God" defense.
>
> > >> I've also heard of amature "landscapers" dropping trees across power =
lines
> > >> and being held responsible for hundreds of electronic devices in thei=
r
> > >> neighborhood damaged by the resulting surge.
>
> > > I had a power transformer blow during a storm and was told it was "an =
act of
> > > God" and the home owners insurance would have to take care of it. =A0T=
here is
> > > nothing with in reason a =A0power comapny could do to prevent that kin=
d of
> > > damage.
>
> > > Much differant than when someone cuts a tree over the power lines.
>
> > During a storm may be different than this case. (No storm mentioned)- Hi=
de quoted text -
>
> > - Show quoted text -
>
> Homeowners insurance will pay but when working off a $500 deductible
> with a $150 microwave oven and $100 worth of surge protectors, it was
> not even considered. =A0That year we had 11 power outages with average
> of about one day each.
>
> Delmarva Power admitted that =A0they had saved $3 million that year by
> cutting back in tree trimming. =A0Me and all my neighbors now have
> backup generators.
>
> My cumulative damages were about $600 so insurance was not worth
> considering.
> My brother had a lightening strike on light pole outside his house
> that took out all his electronic equipment so insurance paid.

Well, so far my damages are $110 for the power supply in the air
filter (found online; still waiting on a quote from the guy that
installed it) appx. $200 for the TVSS, and unknown for the dishwasher
(previous owners paid $550 for it, installed.) I'm not counting the
surge strip as it was fully depreciated years ago.

SWMBO called around to various people today as I was too busy at work
to take care of it; they are apparently considering claims for
damages. Sounds like I got off light as a coworker that lives a
couple streets over (in the direction of the transformer that blew, if
my directional hearing isn't completely shot) lost at least a couple
of TVs and he has not fully assessed his damages yet. So this may get
taken care of; we'll see. The only problem is that according to both
the power company and the insurance company, there are a LOT of claims
in my area so it may take a few days for someone to assess it. Air
filter; well I can live without that for a while especially given that
the current weather is such that neither the furnace nor the A/C is
running a lot; the diswasher is another issue entirely - I'm a lazy
bastard, goshdarnit, and I like to have menial household chores taken
care of for me automatically! :)

This experience has got me thinking, though - the furnace itself does
have an electronic control board; would it be a prudent investment to
install some kind of surge suppression right at the furnace to protect
it and the air cleaner should this happen again? The furnace is
something close to 20 years old - I forget exactly when it was
installed, but I did find the receipt for it in some old paperwork -
and I imagine finding a replacement board for that might not be so
easy/inexpensive.

nate

Posted by Bob F on May 14, 2008, 1:06 am


This experience has got me thinking, though - the furnace itself does
have an electronic control board; would it be a prudent investment to
install some kind of surge suppression right at the furnace to protect
it and the air cleaner should this happen again? The furnace is
something close to 20 years old - I forget exactly when it was
installed, but I did find the receipt for it in some old paperwork -
and I imagine finding a replacement board for that might not be so
easy/inexpensive.

*******************************************************

A whole house surge protector would probably be your best bet.



Posted by N8N on May 14, 2008, 8:17 am
>
>
> This experience has got me thinking, though - the furnace itself does
> have an electronic control board; would it be a prudent investment to
> install some kind of surge suppression right at the furnace to protect
> it and the air cleaner should this happen again? =A0The furnace is
> something close to 20 years old - I forget exactly when it was
> installed, but I did find the receipt for it in some old paperwork -
> and I imagine finding a replacement board for that might not be so
> easy/inexpensive.
>
> *******************************************************
>
> A whole house surge protector would probably be your best bet.

I already have (well, had) the Siemens TVSS breaker in my panel. I'm
assuming it was functional prior to this incident. This is why I'm
thinking of adding additional point of use protection. I did find a
local source for a replacement breaker, but I'll need to get up early
to buy it (they keep contractor's hours)

Also, how is a grounding system tested? I obviously have a ground
wire running outside or I would have done something about it, but
without lots of digging, I can't determine where/how many ground rods
I actually have, and even if I did that I don't know how to evaluate
whether they're providing a good solid connection to ground. What's
the procedure for determining if a grounding system is adequate?

nate

Similar ThreadsPosted
Re: damage from blown transformer? May 12, 2008, 7:26 pm
Re: damage from blown transformer? May 12, 2008, 10:19 pm
Gas boiler transformer blown August 27, 2006, 12:16 pm
Goodman HVAC system control problem- blown transformer June 9, 2008, 7:03 pm
boiler transformer February 28, 2007, 6:37 pm
Oil leaking out of pole transformer June 29, 2005, 5:45 am
Doorbell transformer wattage July 3, 2005, 1:54 pm
Transformer question (puzzled) April 12, 2007, 12:49 pm
REPLACE FURNACE TRANSFORMER January 6, 2007, 5:53 pm
Malibu Transformer Question March 15, 2007, 2:39 pm

Contact Us | Privacy Policy

XML SitemapXML Sitemap