Home Page link

Roofing Question

Home Repair - - If it ain't broken, don't fix it. Otherwise look here. 

Page 4 of 15       < 1 2 3 > last >> Bookmark this page:  YahooMyWeb Yahoo!  Google Google  Windows Live Favorites Windows Live  del.icio.us del.icio.us  digg digg  Add to Netscape Netscape
Subject Author Date
Roofing Question Clueless Mary 07-07-2007
If you were  Registered and logged in, you could reply and use other advanced thread options
Posted by RicodJour on July 8, 2007, 9:39 am
> RicodJour wrote:
>
> ...
>
> > That's something that's always pissed me off. The big box stores do
> > an end run around the contracting licensing laws because of some
> > stupid contention that they are not contractors, but suppliers. Well,
> > when someone supplies material and labor under one contract, that
> > makes them a contractor. When they sub out the work, that makes them
> > a general contractor.
>
> > The big box stores don't participate in restitution funds, obey the
> > maximum deposit regulations, etc., etc. It's just wrong.
>
> So don't use them...if you could convince enough others (just like in
> the argument against cheap/inferior/import/whatever merchandise threads)
> they would either change their ways or quit offering the service...

People would always use them. They know the name, they have low
prices and high exposure. How many contractors do you know that have
their own NASCAR team? They're the 900 pound gorilla, so people who
don't know any better think they've gotta be good and don't know the
alternatives.

They operate like a contractor, they should be held to the same rules
and regulations. It's similar to saying that someone is not in the
legislative branch so they don't have to comply with legislative
directives, and then that they're not in the executive branch when
they don't want to comply with executive directives. It's just
stupid.

R


AppliancePartsPros.com, Inc.
Posted by dpb on July 8, 2007, 9:51 am
RicodJour wrote:
>> RicodJour wrote:
>>
>> ...
>>
>>> That's something that's always pissed me off. The big box stores do
>>> an end run around the contracting licensing laws because of some
>>> stupid contention that they are not contractors, but suppliers. Well,
>>> when someone supplies material and labor under one contract, that
>>> makes them a contractor. When they sub out the work, that makes them
>>> a general contractor.
>>> The big box stores don't participate in restitution funds, obey the
>>> maximum deposit regulations, etc., etc. It's just wrong.
>> So don't use them...if you could convince enough others (just like in
>> the argument against cheap/inferior/import/whatever merchandise threads)
>> they would either change their ways or quit offering the service...
>
> People would always use them. They know the name, they have low
> prices and high exposure. ...

Then they must be doing something right for their business model.

Who you want to be complaining to is either your legislature or
enforcement depending on whether there isn't appropriate/adequate
legislation in your opinion or there is lax enforcement of existing
regulation. Same fundamental truth -- get enough widespread support and
raise enough clamor and you can be the effector of change. Otherwise,
your way to vote is by your own choice.

(And to be clear, not a personal attack intended, simply a pov on how/to
whom/where to complain/bitch/protest...)

--


--

Posted by RicodJour on July 8, 2007, 10:17 am
> RicodJour wrote:
> >> RicodJour wrote:
>
> >> ...
>
> >>> That's something that's always pissed me off. The big box stores do
> >>> an end run around the contracting licensing laws because of some
> >>> stupid contention that they are not contractors, but suppliers. Well,
> >>> when someone supplies material and labor under one contract, that
> >>> makes them a contractor. When they sub out the work, that makes them
> >>> a general contractor.
> >>> The big box stores don't participate in restitution funds, obey the
> >>> maximum deposit regulations, etc., etc. It's just wrong.
> >> So don't use them...if you could convince enough others (just like in
> >> the argument against cheap/inferior/import/whatever merchandise threads)
> >> they would either change their ways or quit offering the service...
>
> > People would always use them. They know the name, they have low
> > prices and high exposure. ...
>
> Then they must be doing something right for their business model.
>
> Who you want to be complaining to is either your legislature or
> enforcement depending on whether there isn't appropriate/adequate
> legislation in your opinion or there is lax enforcement of existing
> regulation. Same fundamental truth -- get enough widespread support and
> raise enough clamor and you can be the effector of change. Otherwise,
> your way to vote is by your own choice.
>
> (And to be clear, not a personal attack intended, simply a pov on how/to
> whom/where to complain/bitch/protest...)

Well, in one way, they're good for my business. Horror stories tend
to loosen up the pocketbooks, and god knows there are enough big box
installer horror stories. ;)

Going up against Home Depot would need to be a crusade, and I have
enough of them at the moment, but your point is well taken.

R



Posted by dpb on July 8, 2007, 10:32 am
RicodJour wrote:
>> RicodJour wrote:
>>>> RicodJour wrote:
>>>> ...
>>>>> That's something that's always pissed me off. The big box stores do
>>>>> an end run around the contracting licensing laws because of some
>>>>> stupid contention that they are not contractors, but suppliers. Well,
>>>>> when someone supplies material and labor under one contract, that
>>>>> makes them a contractor. When they sub out the work, that makes them
>>>>> a general contractor.
>>>>> The big box stores don't participate in restitution funds, obey the
>>>>> maximum deposit regulations, etc., etc. It's just wrong.
>>>> So don't use them...if you could convince enough others (just like in
>>>> the argument against cheap/inferior/import/whatever merchandise threads)
>>>> they would either change their ways or quit offering the service...
>>> People would always use them. They know the name, they have low
>>> prices and high exposure. ...
>> Then they must be doing something right for their business model.
>>
>> Who you want to be complaining to is either your legislature or
>> enforcement depending on whether there isn't appropriate/adequate
>> legislation in your opinion or there is lax enforcement of existing
>> regulation. Same fundamental truth -- get enough widespread support and
>> raise enough clamor and you can be the effector of change. Otherwise,
>> your way to vote is by your own choice.
>>
>> (And to be clear, not a personal attack intended, simply a pov on how/to
>> whom/where to complain/bitch/protest...)
>
> Well, in one way, they're good for my business. Horror stories tend
> to loosen up the pocketbooks, and god knows there are enough big box
> installer horror stories. ;)
>
> Going up against Home Depot would need to be a crusade, and I have
> enough of them at the moment, but your point is well taken.

Amen to both! :)

But, imo there are two general classes that choose the box store as
installer for a project -- the incurably cheap and the incurably
naive/uneducated/uninformed. Neither is what you want as a client,
either, until they have at least had an eduction. :(

As I've pointed out in previous threads on the topic, in present US
consumer circles there seems to be an endless supply of people wanting
the lowest initial cost whatever it is and more of whatever "it" is
currently. As long as this mentality reigns predominant, the trend to
such behavior by the retailers will also continue to follow the market,
however much those who prefer small/independent/high(er) quality/etc.,
decry it. So far, there seems to be at least a survivable niche for
most independent remodelers, etc. The folks really getting squeezed out
are the small retailers, etc., that can't compete on the "bread and
butter" items that formerly allowed them to be able to stock the
lower-volume products.

--

Posted by Robert Allison on July 8, 2007, 5:05 pm
dpb wrote:
> RicodJour wrote:
>
>>
>>> RicodJour wrote:
>>>
>>>>
>>>>> RicodJour wrote:
>>>>> ...
>>>>>
>>>>>> That's something that's always pissed me off. The big box stores do
>>>>>> an end run around the contracting licensing laws because of some
>>>>>> stupid contention that they are not contractors, but suppliers.
>>>>>> Well,
>>>>>> when someone supplies material and labor under one contract, that
>>>>>> makes them a contractor. When they sub out the work, that makes them
>>>>>> a general contractor.
>>>>>> The big box stores don't participate in restitution funds, obey the
>>>>>> maximum deposit regulations, etc., etc. It's just wrong.
>>>>>
>>>>> So don't use them...if you could convince enough others (just like in
>>>>> the argument against cheap/inferior/import/whatever merchandise
>>>>> threads)
>>>>> they would either change their ways or quit offering the service...
>>>>
>>>> People would always use them. They know the name, they have low
>>>> prices and high exposure. ...
>>>
>>> Then they must be doing something right for their business model.
>>>
>>> Who you want to be complaining to is either your legislature or
>>> enforcement depending on whether there isn't appropriate/adequate
>>> legislation in your opinion or there is lax enforcement of existing
>>> regulation. Same fundamental truth -- get enough widespread support and
>>> raise enough clamor and you can be the effector of change. Otherwise,
>>> your way to vote is by your own choice.
>>>
>>> (And to be clear, not a personal attack intended, simply a pov on how/to
>>> whom/where to complain/bitch/protest...)
>>
>>
>> Well, in one way, they're good for my business. Horror stories tend
>> to loosen up the pocketbooks, and god knows there are enough big box
>> installer horror stories. ;)
>>
>> Going up against Home Depot would need to be a crusade, and I have
>> enough of them at the moment, but your point is well taken.
>
>
> Amen to both! :)
>
> But, imo there are two general classes that choose the box store as
> installer for a project -- the incurably cheap and the incurably
> naive/uneducated/uninformed. Neither is what you want as a client,
> either, until they have at least had an eduction. :(

I think that a lot of the customers for HD and Lowes
installation are people that use credit for everything. A lot
of these people could never afford to dish out the money for a
project, so they use the plastic and not only pay in advance,
but with interest alot more than they would if they paid cash.

> As I've pointed out in previous threads on the topic, in present US
> consumer circles there seems to be an endless supply of people wanting
> the lowest initial cost whatever it is and more of whatever "it" is
> currently. As long as this mentality reigns predominant, the trend to
> such behavior by the retailers will also continue to follow the market,
> however much those who prefer small/independent/high(er) quality/etc.,
> decry it. So far, there seems to be at least a survivable niche for
> most independent remodelers, etc. The folks really getting squeezed out
> are the small retailers, etc., that can't compete on the "bread and
> butter" items that formerly allowed them to be able to stock the
> lower-volume products.
>
> --

We small, quality contractors will always be around, because
there are a lot of quality minded consumers still around. I
cannot do all the work that I am asked to do, yet I never
advertise, nor am I in the yellow pages. I just do good work.
I am constantly amazed when a person calls out of the blue and
we go over who knew who and who recommended me. (And I always
get a deposit up front, or at the least, when the materials
are delivered. But I never start work without a little money
in my pocket.)

--
Robert Allison        
Rimshot, Inc.
Georgetown, TX

Page 4 of 15       < 1 2 3 > last >>
Similar ThreadsPosted
Roofing question October 4, 2005, 9:25 pm
Re: Question about roofing June 27, 2005, 7:32 am
Question about roofing June 25, 2005, 11:08 pm
roofing question March 24, 2006, 8:49 pm
re-roofing question July 1, 2006, 1:20 pm
Roofing Question May 22, 2007, 6:24 pm
Another Roofing Question May 27, 2007, 11:51 am
Roofing Question July 27, 2007, 4:33 pm
Roofing Question August 15, 2007, 12:33 pm
Question about roofing September 18, 2007, 8:35 am

Contact Us | Privacy Policy

XML SitemapXML Sitemap