Home Page link

Strange Electrical Problem

Home Repair - - If it ain't broken, don't fix it. Otherwise look here. 

Page 1 of 5       1 2 3 > last >> Bookmark this page:  YahooMyWeb Yahoo!  Google Google  Windows Live Favorites Windows Live  del.icio.us del.icio.us  digg digg  Add to Netscape Netscape
Subject Author Date
Strange Electrical Problem Ajax 01-30-2006
If you were  Registered and logged in, you could reply and use other advanced thread options
Posted by Ajax on January 30, 2006, 11:10 pm

When one of our neighbors came back from vacation they found that the
20 amp single pole breaker for their hot tub and the 20 amp single
pole breaker for their refrigerator in their detached garage had
tripped. Neither GFCI type outlet served by these breakers had
tripped.

The Garage circuit was about 12 years old and the hot tub circuit was
only weeks old. The two breakers are not in close proximity to each
other in the main panel.

They reset both breakers and they have not tripped since [two weeks].

Today the sixty amp double pole breaker that is feeding a recently
built master bedroom / bathroom tripped. This breaker feeds from the
main panel to a subpanel that houses the breakers for the addition.

The subpanel includes two 20 amp single pole Arc-Fault breakers for
the bedroom, two twenty amp single pole breakers that feed directly to
two GFCI type outlets in the bathroom and two unassigned breakers.

At the time the 60 amp breaker tripped only the two Arc-Fault
breakers were turned on. Neither of the Arc-Fault breakers tripped.
Therefore it seems unlikely that an event from the new room caused the
60 amp breaker to trip.

At the time of the trip, the total load on the 60 amp breaker, via
the new addition subpanel, was comprised of one digital one analog
alarm clock.

Prior to and after the 60 amp breaker tripped the branch circuits
served by the new addition subpanel were tested with an Ideal #61-155
circuit analyzer.

This device tests for a host of electrical problems, including: True
RMS, voltage drop, line voltage, peak voltage, frequency, ground
impedance, hot and neutral impedance, ground-neutral voltage, false
and false grounds. Everything tested perfectly.

It also successfully tested the GFCI outlet devices and the Arc-
Fault breakers.

This test runs the entire circuit, including the conductors used
between the main panel and the new subpanel and the new 60 amp double
pole breaker in the main panel that supplies the new subpanel.

Assuming that any trouble in the new addition would have tripped the
Arc-Fault breakers, we guessed that the problem must lie somewhere
between the new subpanel and the existing main panel. This would
reduce the scope of the search to the conductor, the new 60 amp double
pole breaker and the main panel.

The conductor is brand new copper UF cable. The Ideal meter test
showed no indication of high impedance. An inspection of the main
panel showed no indication of a short circuit, arcing or overheating.

When the 60 amp double pole breaker was turned back on it stayed on
and was cold to the touch. When checked thirty minutes later with an
infrared thermometer, the temperature was normal, as were the rest of
the breakers.

It should be noted that the 60 amp circuit that supplies power to the
subpanel for the room addition had been turned on over six weeks ago
and had operated flawlessly until this afternoon.

Any one of the single pole breakers tripping would just be an anomaly
that would not need to be answered unless the problem recurred. But
the 60 amp double pole breaker tripping under no load has caused my
friends some concern.

Can anyone think of a circumstance that would cause the problems that
they experienced?

TIA

Posted by Al Moran on January 30, 2006, 11:43 pm


> Can anyone think of a circumstance that would cause the problems that
>they experienced?
> TIA


I know exactly why, somethings fucked up and they need to get the
contractor back out there before the house burns down.

Posted by Ajax on January 31, 2006, 8:40 am
wrote:

>> Can anyone think of a circumstance that would cause the problems that
>>they experienced?
>> TIA
>I know exactly why, somethings fucked up and they need to get the
>contractor back out there before the house burns down.

Thanks for the insightful review of the problem, Al. The contractor
and the electrician have both been to the job and both are baffled.
The electrician spent hours testing the system with everything testing
perfectly.



Posted by Larry Fishel on January 31, 2006, 1:55 am
Just a couple of real WAGs.

Surges on the supply line?
Vermin crawling through the breaker box?
A prankster in the house?


Posted by RBM on January 31, 2006, 7:03 am
Were the handles of the breakers found in the "tripped" position or the
"off" position, and what brand circuit breaker?


> When one of our neighbors came back from vacation they found that the
> 20 amp single pole breaker for their hot tub and the 20 amp single
> pole breaker for their refrigerator in their detached garage had
> tripped. Neither GFCI type outlet served by these breakers had
> tripped.
> The Garage circuit was about 12 years old and the hot tub circuit was
> only weeks old. The two breakers are not in close proximity to each
> other in the main panel.
> They reset both breakers and they have not tripped since [two weeks].
> Today the sixty amp double pole breaker that is feeding a recently
> built master bedroom / bathroom tripped. This breaker feeds from the
> main panel to a subpanel that houses the breakers for the addition.
> The subpanel includes two 20 amp single pole Arc-Fault breakers for
> the bedroom, two twenty amp single pole breakers that feed directly to
> two GFCI type outlets in the bathroom and two unassigned breakers.
> At the time the 60 amp breaker tripped only the two Arc-Fault
> breakers were turned on. Neither of the Arc-Fault breakers tripped.
> Therefore it seems unlikely that an event from the new room caused the
> 60 amp breaker to trip.
> At the time of the trip, the total load on the 60 amp breaker, via
> the new addition subpanel, was comprised of one digital one analog
> alarm clock.
> Prior to and after the 60 amp breaker tripped the branch circuits
> served by the new addition subpanel were tested with an Ideal #61-155
> circuit analyzer.
> This device tests for a host of electrical problems, including: True
> RMS, voltage drop, line voltage, peak voltage, frequency, ground
> impedance, hot and neutral impedance, ground-neutral voltage, false
> and false grounds. Everything tested perfectly.
> It also successfully tested the GFCI outlet devices and the Arc-
> Fault breakers.
> This test runs the entire circuit, including the conductors used
> between the main panel and the new subpanel and the new 60 amp double
> pole breaker in the main panel that supplies the new subpanel.
> Assuming that any trouble in the new addition would have tripped the
> Arc-Fault breakers, we guessed that the problem must lie somewhere
> between the new subpanel and the existing main panel. This would
> reduce the scope of the search to the conductor, the new 60 amp double
> pole breaker and the main panel.
> The conductor is brand new copper UF cable. The Ideal meter test
> showed no indication of high impedance. An inspection of the main
> panel showed no indication of a short circuit, arcing or overheating.
> When the 60 amp double pole breaker was turned back on it stayed on
> and was cold to the touch. When checked thirty minutes later with an
> infrared thermometer, the temperature was normal, as were the rest of
> the breakers.
> It should be noted that the 60 amp circuit that supplies power to the
> subpanel for the room addition had been turned on over six weeks ago
> and had operated flawlessly until this afternoon.
> Any one of the single pole breakers tripping would just be an anomaly
> that would not need to be answered unless the problem recurred. But
> the 60 amp double pole breaker tripping under no load has caused my
> friends some concern.
> Can anyone think of a circumstance that would cause the problems that
> they experienced?
> TIA



Page 1 of 5       1 2 3 > last >>
Similar ThreadsPosted
Strange electrical problem May 22, 2007, 8:07 pm
** 3-way electrical light switch (strange problem) ** February 14, 2007, 2:41 am
Followup on strange electrical box. July 6, 2007, 11:28 pm
Strange Electrical outlet December 7, 2005, 10:11 am
Strange Electrical Circuit January 1, 2007, 10:00 pm
Strange problem August 4, 2005, 7:22 pm
Strange A/C Problem?? June 4, 2006, 2:39 pm
strange gfi problem August 20, 2007, 9:27 pm
Strange fuse problem July 23, 2007, 3:12 pm
Strange Heat Radiation Problem November 4, 2005, 11:33 am

Contact Us | Privacy Policy

XML SitemapXML Sitemap