Home Page link

Unfrozen Toilet tank bolts

Home Repair - - If it ain't broken, don't fix it. Otherwise look here. 

Page 2 of 3       < 1 2 3 > last >> Bookmark this page:  YahooMyWeb Yahoo!  Google Google  Windows Live Favorites Windows Live  del.icio.us del.icio.us  digg digg  Add to Netscape Netscape
Subject Author Date
Unfrozen Toilet tank bolts jJim McLaughlin 08-11-2007
If you were  Registered and logged in, you could reply and use other advanced thread options
Posted by DerbyDad03 on August 11, 2007, 11:11 pm
- Any thoughts on a lube or thread proctectant for the
- bolt threads before reassembling things so I don't run into this
issue
- again?

Don't take the tank off next time and you won't run into the issue
again.

Now, please don't think I'm just being a smart-a** here. I look at it
this way:

If the tank and bowl can be moved and stored as a single unit, why add
any risk of damage or leaks by separating them? Even if you're 100%
sure (and who can be?) that nothing will happen during disassembly/
reassembly, why do the extra work?

In your original thread I said OK when you said "You do it your way,
I'll do it mine" and I mean that. However, just like in the original
thread, I'm asking *why*. I've explained why I do it my way, and I'm
simply curious as to why you do it your way. Maybe I'll learn
something, and isn't that why we hang out in this group - to give and
get advice on home repair?

So, if you wouldn't mind, please share your reasons for taking the
tank off. I promise not to argue or criticize. I'm simply curious.

Thanks!

wrote:
> Finally got the frozen nut off the bolt yesterday. Didn't have to
> use the hacksaw.
>
> Apparently enough 0f the liquid wrench stuff had soaked in, and when I
> tried it
> Friday morning with the wrench / vise grips and screwdriver I was able
> to get
> the nut off and the tank dismounted.
>
> Got the bowl out easily, and started pulling the old sheet vinyl and
> thats all
> coming along well.
>
> Still thinking about the tank bolts though.
>
> Nowadays, almost all toilet seat attachment hardware is the nylon bolt type.
>
> Why not nylon bolts / nuts for the tank / bowl attachent?
>
> When I was at Ace Thursday afternoon picking up a new wax ring for bowl
> re installation, I looked for nylon tank attachment hardware figuring
> that
> I'd have to replace the nut / bolt I thought I was going to have to saw
> through.
> No such animal. Only brass tank attachment stuff. I didn't think to
> ask the
> guy at Ace, who is usually pretty knowledgable. I picked up a set of
> brass hardware,
> which I will eventually have to return.
>
> Anybody know why apparently no nylon tank bolt attachment hardware?
>
> Second issue: I'm cleaning up the bolt threads in a wire wheel in the
> drill press. All nice and clean now. Really interesting aglommeration
> of green, blue,
> white and all shades in between of corrosion and crud now gone. It was
> concentrated
> where the nut was on the bolt, and below the nut.
>
> Any thoughts on a lube or thread proctectant for the
> bolt threads before reassembling things so I don't run into this issue
> again?
>
> (Yeah, I know, if its another 37 years on this specific toilet, it will
> be someone elses problem, not mine.)
>
> But is there a reason not to use a simple lube like white lithium grease
> or even
> vaseline on the brass threads on the bolt and inside the nut?
>
> Thanks.



PexSupply Save 10 468x60
Posted by aemeijers on August 12, 2007, 1:07 am

> Finally got the frozen nut off the bolt yesterday. Didn't have to use
> the hacksaw.
>
> Apparently enough 0f the liquid wrench stuff had soaked in, and when I
> tried it
> Friday morning with the wrench / vise grips and screwdriver I was able to
> get
> the nut off and the tank dismounted.
>
> Got the bowl out easily, and started pulling the old sheet vinyl and thats
> all
> coming along well.
>
> Still thinking about the tank bolts though.
>
> Nowadays, almost all toilet seat attachment hardware is the nylon bolt
> type.
>
> Why not nylon bolts / nuts for the tank / bowl attachent?
>
> When I was at Ace Thursday afternoon picking up a new wax ring for bowl
> re installation, I looked for nylon tank attachment hardware figuring
> that
> I'd have to replace the nut / bolt I thought I was going to have to saw
> through.
> No such animal. Only brass tank attachment stuff. I didn't think to ask
> the
> guy at Ace, who is usually pretty knowledgable. I picked up a set of brass
> hardware,
> which I will eventually have to return.
>
> Anybody know why apparently no nylon tank bolt attachment hardware?
>
> Second issue: I'm cleaning up the bolt threads in a wire wheel in the
> drill press. All nice and clean now. Really interesting aglommeration of
> green, blue,
> white and all shades in between of corrosion and crud now gone. It was
> concentrated
> where the nut was on the bolt, and below the nut.
>
> Any thoughts on a lube or thread proctectant for the
> bolt threads before reassembling things so I don't run into this issue
> again?
>
> (Yeah, I know, if its another 37 years on this specific toilet, it will
> be someone elses problem, not mine.)
>
> But is there a reason not to use a simple lube like white lithium grease
> or even
> vaseline on the brass threads on the bolt and inside the nut?
>
Dumb question- I know we have a hundred years of tradition saying use brass
for applications like this. But in the modern world, wouldn't a good grade
of stainless steel be a better choice? That is what I use for wet-area
work, if I think I will ever need to take it apart again. On boats, isn't
stainless for fasteners pretty well universal these days? Piss and seawater
are pretty close in salt and chemical content, after all. I'd happily pay an
extra couple of bucks for a bolt kit I knew I wouldn't have to cut off five
years later. (I HATE plastic toilet seat bolts- the damn things will NOT
stay tight more than a couple of weeks.)

aem sends...

aem sends....



Posted by DerbyDad03 on August 12, 2007, 1:12 am
>
>
>
>
> > Finally got the frozen nut off the bolt yesterday. Didn't have to use
> > the hacksaw.
>
> > Apparently enough 0f the liquid wrench stuff had soaked in, and when I
> > tried it
> > Friday morning with the wrench / vise grips and screwdriver I was able to
> > get
> > the nut off and the tank dismounted.
>
> > Got the bowl out easily, and started pulling the old sheet vinyl and thats
> > all
> > coming along well.
>
> > Still thinking about the tank bolts though.
>
> > Nowadays, almost all toilet seat attachment hardware is the nylon bolt
> > type.
>
> > Why not nylon bolts / nuts for the tank / bowl attachent?
>
> > When I was at Ace Thursday afternoon picking up a new wax ring for bowl
> > re installation, I looked for nylon tank attachment hardware figuring
> > that
> > I'd have to replace the nut / bolt I thought I was going to have to saw
> > through.
> > No such animal. Only brass tank attachment stuff. I didn't think to ask
> > the
> > guy at Ace, who is usually pretty knowledgable. I picked up a set of brass
> > hardware,
> > which I will eventually have to return.
>
> > Anybody know why apparently no nylon tank bolt attachment hardware?
>
> > Second issue: I'm cleaning up the bolt threads in a wire wheel in the
> > drill press. All nice and clean now. Really interesting aglommeration of
> > green, blue,
> > white and all shades in between of corrosion and crud now gone. It was
> > concentrated
> > where the nut was on the bolt, and below the nut.
>
> > Any thoughts on a lube or thread proctectant for the
> > bolt threads before reassembling things so I don't run into this issue
> > again?
>
> > (Yeah, I know, if its another 37 years on this specific toilet, it will
> > be someone elses problem, not mine.)
>
> > But is there a reason not to use a simple lube like white lithium grease
> > or even
> > vaseline on the brass threads on the bolt and inside the nut?
>
> Dumb question- I know we have a hundred years of tradition saying use brass
> for applications like this. But in the modern world, wouldn't a good grade
> of stainless steel be a better choice? That is what I use for wet-area
> work, if I think I will ever need to take it apart again. On boats, isn't
> stainless for fasteners pretty well universal these days? Piss and seawater
> are pretty close in salt and chemical content, after all. I'd happily pay an
> extra couple of bucks for a bolt kit I knew I wouldn't have to cut off five
> years later. (I HATE plastic toilet seat bolts- the damn things will NOT
> stay tight more than a couple of weeks.)
>
> aem sends...
>
> aem sends....- Hide quoted text -
>
> - Show quoted text -

Do you piss into and/or under the tank of your toilet? You do realize
that this discussion is about the bolts that hold the tank onto the
bowl. If you're pissing on those bolts, you need to learn how to aim
better.


Posted by aemeijers on August 12, 2007, 5:10 am

>>
>>
>>
>>
(Snip)>> - Show quoted text -
>
> Do you piss into and/or under the tank of your toilet? You do realize
> that this discussion is about the bolts that hold the tank onto the
> bowl. If you're pissing on those bolts, you need to learn how to aim
> better.

Yes, I know it is the tank bolts. Yes, people do miss (in the dark) once in
a while. Even if not direct hits, it is still a wet environment, from
condensation in summer, if nothing else, and gets cleaned with pretty harsh
stuff that throws off fumes that corrode metals, and leaks into the crack
between stool and tank.

The tank bolts and the seat bolts are only inches apart, and someone else
brought up plastic bolts.

aem sends...



Posted by mm on August 12, 2007, 5:28 am
On Sat, 11 Aug 2007 16:08:54 -0700, jJim McLaughlin

>
>Anybody know why apparently no nylon tank bolt attachment hardware?

My guess is that they snap or rip after a while.

If this happens with the toilet seat, just make sure you don't flush
yourself down.
>
>Second issue: I'm cleaning up the bolt threads in a wire wheel in the
>drill press. All nice and clean now. Really interesting aglommeration
>of green, blue,
>white and all shades in between of corrosion and crud now gone. It was
>concentrated
>where the nut was on the bolt, and below the nut.
>
>Any thoughts on a lube or thread proctectant for the
>bolt threads before reassembling things so I don't run into this issue
>again?
>
>(Yeah, I know, if its another 37 years on this specific toilet, it will
>be someone elses problem, not mine.)

When doing repairs, I care about others almost as much as myself. I
would say the reason not to worry is it's only once every 37 years.
If you need to remove the toilet in 20 years, it won't be as hard as
it was this time.

Reading other answers: I've only replaced one toilet. Another guy
took it off in one piece and I put it back on in one piece. It wasn't
hard. I think I only lifted it at one end, probably leaving the front
edge on the floor.

(I also didn't replace the wax ring, because it disgusted me and I was
doing her a favor. The house and toilet were almost new, less than a
year. I saw her for another 6 months and it didn't give any problems
in that time.

>But is there a reason not to use a simple lube like white lithium grease
>or even
>vaseline on the brass threads on the bolt and inside the nut?

The bolts might come off when you don't want them too? Just a guess.

>Thanks.


Page 2 of 3       < 1 2 3 > last >>
Similar ThreadsPosted
Removing toilet tank ? (no tank bolts - where are they ?) June 4, 2006, 1:23 pm
rusty toilet tank bolts November 5, 2007, 12:48 am
Toilet Tank Bolts -- Frozen - Removal August 9, 2007, 4:15 pm
Anchoring toilet floor bolts August 19, 2008, 12:47 pm
Toilet Tank Leak - Maybe a cracked tank? January 14, 2007, 2:02 am
Toilet Tank, Meet Toilet Bowl... August 6, 2008, 8:35 pm
bolting toilet tank to toilet bow August 5, 2008, 5:46 pm
toilet tank float November 27, 2005, 3:47 pm
toilet tank condensation December 28, 2005, 12:37 am
Toilet tank sweating February 8, 2007, 1:14 pm

Contact Us | Privacy Policy

XML SitemapXML Sitemap