Home Page link

What should I do when nail in shingle hits sheathing's crack?

Home Repair - - If it ain't broken, don't fix it. Otherwise look here. 

Bookmark this page:  YahooMyWeb Yahoo!  Google Google  Windows Live Favorites Windows Live  del.icio.us del.icio.us  digg digg  Add to Netscape Netscape
Subject Author Date
What should I do when nail in shingle hits sheathing's crack? DJW 05-03-2007
If you were  Registered and logged in, you could reply and use other advanced thread options
Posted by DJW on May 3, 2007, 8:33 am


I am applying three tab Owens corning as to their nailing instructions
with a hammer by placing the nail below the seal strip and above the
split that forms the tabs. What should I do if my nail hits nothing?
It is old plank sheathing 1940s vintage and when by chance the nail
area is over the crack between boards I have found that one to three
(or worst case all four) nails just go in fast and hit nothing. I have
then at least been putting two more nails above the seal strip. I can
figure no other option. I assume I should not pull the bad nails
because of the hole created by them. I am concerned down the road that
they may pop up a bit and effect the shingle over them. But what else
could be done. When a nail goes in without hitting anything I try to
adjust the next one over sometime with success and some times with the
same no hit results. I start to use profanity when the next two or
more do the same.


Tankless Water Heaters 468x60
Posted by dpb on May 3, 2007, 10:16 am


> I am applying three tab Owens corning as to their nailing instructions
> with a hammer by placing the nail below the seal strip and above the
> split that forms the tabs. What should I do if my nail hits nothing?
> It is old plank sheathing 1940s vintage and when by chance the nail
> area is over the crack between boards I have found that one to three
> (or worst case all four) nails just go in fast and hit nothing. I have
> then at least been putting two more nails above the seal strip. I can
> figure no other option. I assume I should not pull the bad nails
> because of the hole created by them. I am concerned down the road that
> they may pop up a bit and effect the shingle over them. But what else
> could be done. When a nail goes in without hitting anything I try to
> adjust the next one over sometime with success and some times with the
> same no hit results. I start to use profanity when the next two or
> more do the same.

A plank sheathing roof should be in-filled or lay a plywood nailing
overlayer over the sheathing before laying asphalt shingles to
eliminate the problem. If the gaps aren't wide enough to in-fill w/
1x, you're only choice is (best) the overlay (sounds like too late for
that here, unfortunately) or to adjust the nailing pattern to
accomdate the location of the sheathing.

W/O seeing your particular roof, can only suggest filling in the
portion you haven't reached so far before you get there. If you have
to adjust the nailing pattern excessively, you're bound to have
problems down the road and if there are a large number left in which
nails didn't have anything to hold, those rows will undoubtedly fail
early in a strong blow...if you're where the wind never blows much,
you may get by, but it would never last a year out here where.


Posted by Goedjn on May 3, 2007, 12:43 pm



>> I am applying three tab Owens corning as to their nailing instructions
>> with a hammer by placing the nail below the seal strip and above the
>> split that forms the tabs. What should I do if my nail hits nothing?
>> It is old plank sheathing 1940s vintage and when by chance the nail
>> area is over the crack between boards I have found that one to three
>> (or worst case all four) nails just go in fast and hit nothing. I have
>> then at least been putting two more nails above the seal strip. I can
>> figure no other option. I assume I should not pull the bad nails
>> because of the hole created by them. I am concerned down the road that
>> they may pop up a bit and effect the shingle over them. But what else
>> could be done. When a nail goes in without hitting anything I try to
>> adjust the next one over sometime with success and some times with the
>> same no hit results. I start to use profanity when the next two or
>> more do the same.
>
>A plank sheathing roof should be in-filled or lay a plywood nailing
>overlayer over the sheathing before laying asphalt shingles to
>eliminate the problem. If the gaps aren't wide enough to in-fill w/
>1x, you're only choice is (best) the overlay (sounds like too late for
>that here, unfortunately) or to adjust the nailing pattern to
>accomdate the location of the sheathing.
>
>W/O seeing your particular roof, can only suggest filling in the
>portion you haven't reached so far before you get there. If you have
>to adjust the nailing pattern excessively, you're bound to have
>problems down the road and if there are a large number left in which
>nails didn't have anything to hold, those rows will undoubtedly fail
>early in a strong blow...if you're where the wind never blows much,
>you may get by, but it would never last a year out here where.

Since it's too late to conveniently fix the decking,
is the skip-sheathing a regular size? If so, you should
be able to shrink the shingle exposure to match the spacing
of the gaps. IOW, if the decking planks are
8.5" on-center, set the shingles with 4.25" exposure instead
of 5", or whatever you'd normally use. If the shingles
you're using have special gluing instructions for high-wind
exposures, follow those.



Posted by dpb on May 3, 2007, 1:13 pm



Goedjn wrote:
>
> >> I am applying three tab Owens corning as to their nailing instructions
> >> with a hammer by placing the nail below the seal strip and above the
> >> split that forms the tabs. What should I do if my nail hits nothing?
> >> It is old plank sheathing 1940s vintage and when by chance the nail
> >> area is over the crack between boards I have found that one to three
> >> (or worst case all four) nails just go in fast and hit nothing. I have
> >> then at least been putting two more nails above the seal strip. I can
> >> figure no other option. I assume I should not pull the bad nails
> >> because of the hole created by them. I am concerned down the road that
> >> they may pop up a bit and effect the shingle over them. But what else
> >> could be done. When a nail goes in without hitting anything I try to
> >> adjust the next one over sometime with success and some times with the
> >> same no hit results. I start to use profanity when the next two or
> >> more do the same.
> >
> >A plank sheathing roof should be in-filled or lay a plywood nailing
> >overlayer over the sheathing before laying asphalt shingles to
> >eliminate the problem. If the gaps aren't wide enough to in-fill w/
> >1x, you're only choice is (best) the overlay (sounds like too late for
> >that here, unfortunately) or to adjust the nailing pattern to
> >accomdate the location of the sheathing.
> >
> >W/O seeing your particular roof, can only suggest filling in the
> >portion you haven't reached so far before you get there. If you have
> >to adjust the nailing pattern excessively, you're bound to have
> >problems down the road and if there are a large number left in which
> >nails didn't have anything to hold, those rows will undoubtedly fail
> >early in a strong blow...if you're where the wind never blows much,
> >you may get by, but it would never last a year out here where.
>
> Since it's too late to conveniently fix the decking,
> is the skip-sheathing a regular size? If so, you should
> be able to shrink the shingle exposure to match the spacing
> of the gaps. IOW, if the decking planks are
> 8.5" on-center, set the shingles with 4.25" exposure instead
> of 5", or whatever you'd normally use. If the shingles
> you're using have special gluing instructions for high-wind
> exposures, follow those.

Good point, if possible. Often, of course, they weren't "even-enough"
for asphalt but worked fine w/ the intended wood shingles. The roofs
here are a combination of everything from 1x4 to 1x12 and what
initially looks nearly random spacing, but works out for wood at
5-6". The other difficulty may be if has sizable gap there's
insufficient support for the asphalt between planks.

Hopefully, they're close enough and even enough closing up will work,
but I'd suspect he'll just change which row(s) don't line up from one
set to another...


Posted by Al Bundy on May 3, 2007, 8:30 pm


@n76g2000hsh.googlegroups.com:

> I am applying three tab Owens corning as to their nailing instructions
> with a hammer by placing the nail below the seal strip and above the
> split that forms the tabs. What should I do if my nail hits nothing?
> It is old plank sheathing 1940s vintage and when by chance the nail
> area is over the crack between boards I have found that one to three
> (or worst case all four) nails just go in fast and hit nothing. I have
> then at least been putting two more nails above the seal strip. I can
> figure no other option. I assume I should not pull the bad nails
> because of the hole created by them. I am concerned down the road that
> they may pop up a bit and effect the shingle over them. But what else
> could be done. When a nail goes in without hitting anything I try to
> adjust the next one over sometime with success and some times with the
> same no hit results. I start to use profanity when the next two or
> more do the same.
>


Advice alrealy given in other replys but... any nails you see that are
not biting get them out. I would think no nail is better than a loose
one. Will pop through upper shingle and leak. Of course, the water will
actually drip in the house 10ft away.

Similar ThreadsPosted
Most common asphalt shingle nail size February 4, 2007, 1:33 pm
Ashphalt Shingle roof leaks at the nail holes. August 8, 2006, 9:42 pm
Asphalt shingle roofing question: How exposed is an "exposed nail?" November 10, 2005, 4:24 pm
concrete nails/coil nail/roofing nail/umbrella nail November 21, 2005, 9:32 pm
Mower wobbles after blade hits rock. February 16, 2005, 6:53 am
which is better shingle August 16, 2007, 10:36 pm
shingle roofing June 15, 2005, 2:20 pm
Shingle problems January 11, 2006, 10:55 am
Shingle mold June 22, 2006, 1:25 pm
roof shingle missing? January 21, 2006, 9:02 am

Contact Us | Privacy Policy

XML SitemapXML Sitemap