Home Page link

Whole house filter before softener?

Home Repair - - If it ain't broken, don't fix it. Otherwise look here. 

Page 1 of 2       1 2 > last >> Bookmark this page:  YahooMyWeb Yahoo!  Google Google  Windows Live Favorites Windows Live  del.icio.us del.icio.us  digg digg  Add to Netscape Netscape
Subject Author Date
Whole house filter before softener? szilagyic 02-27-2007
If you were  Registered and logged in, you could reply and use other advanced thread options
Posted by szilagyic on February 27, 2007, 2:05 pm


About a year ago I installed a large Whirlpool whole-house filter
housing (model WHCF-DWHBB) before the softener, using carbon-based
filters that have a 3 gallon-per-minute flow rate. My question is,
what is the general opinion on using this filter before the softener,
as opposed to after the softener? Our water has a lot of iron (2
ppm), as we get the rotten egg smell at the farthest faucet and orange
stains in the sinks, etc. I installed this filter before the softener
thinking that I would extend the life of the resin. But lately I have
read some posts that mention this drops the water pressure and can
cause the resin to fail over time. My softener is a 1 cu ft model, if
that helps any. What is the general opinion on installing a filter
like this before this softener?? Should I remove it??

Thank you very much for the feedback!
--
Chris


Posted by Edwin Pawlowski on February 27, 2007, 10:14 pm



> About a year ago I installed a large Whirlpool whole-house filter
> housing (model WHCF-DWHBB) before the softener, using carbon-based
> filters that have a 3 gallon-per-minute flow rate. My question is,
> what is the general opinion on using this filter before the softener,
> as opposed to after the softener? Our water has a lot of iron (2
> ppm), as we get the rotten egg smell at the farthest faucet and orange
> stains in the sinks, etc. I installed this filter before the softener
> thinking that I would extend the life of the resin. But lately I have
> read some posts that mention this drops the water pressure and can
> cause the resin to fail over time. My softener is a 1 cu ft model, if
> that helps any. What is the general opinion on installing a filter
> like this before this softener?? Should I remove it??

Properly maintained, there should be little pressure of volume dropped
across the filter. If you are filtering for solids in the water, yes, it
should be ahead of the softener. If you are filtering for taste, I'd put it
after and only on lines getting the water to drink or cook with.



Posted by szilagyic on February 28, 2007, 12:23 am


>
>
> > About a year ago I installed a large Whirlpool whole-house filter
> > housing (model WHCF-DWHBB) before the softener, using carbon-based
> > filters that have a 3 gallon-per-minute flow rate. My question is,
> > what is the general opinion on using this filter before the softener,
> > as opposed to after the softener? Our water has a lot of iron (2
> > ppm), as we get the rotten egg smell at the farthest faucet and orange
> > stains in the sinks, etc. I installed this filter before the softener
> > thinking that I would extend the life of the resin. But lately I have
> > read some posts that mention this drops the water pressure and can
> > cause the resin to fail over time. My softener is a 1 cu ft model, if
> > that helps any. What is the general opinion on installing a filter
> > like this before this softener?? Should I remove it??
>
> Properly maintained, there should be little pressure of volume dropped
> across the filter. If you are filtering for solids in the water, yes, it
> should be ahead of the softener. If you are filtering for taste, I'd put it
> after and only on lines getting the water to drink or cook with.

Thank you for the input. At each filter change interval (every 3
months), there's about 0.25 inch of orange sludge at the bottom of the
filter housing. There's an orange film that also coats the entire
inside of the housing as well, that I actually have to scrub off. I'm
assuming this is all of the iron, as it's the same color as the stuff
that stains the sinks. Would this be considered solids?? My main
goal was to filter this stuff from getting to the softener, and
further down to the water heater, etc. Will this orange sludge harm
the softener over time, or is the softener meant to handle this
(possibly by using the iron buster green salt)?? Just looking for
suggestions.

Thanks very much ! ...


Posted by D Smith on February 28, 2007, 4:56 pm




>> About a year ago I installed a large Whirlpool whole-house filter
>> housing (model WHCF-DWHBB) before the softener, using carbon-based
>> filters that have a 3 gallon-per-minute flow rate. My question is,
>> what is the general opinion on using this filter before the softener,
>> as opposed to after the softener? Our water has a lot of iron (2
>> ppm), as we get the rotten egg smell at the farthest faucet and orange
>> stains in the sinks, etc. I installed this filter before the softener
>> thinking that I would extend the life of the resin. But lately I have
>> read some posts that mention this drops the water pressure and can
>> cause the resin to fail over time. My softener is a 1 cu ft model, if
>> that helps any. What is the general opinion on installing a filter
>> like this before this softener?? Should I remove it??

>Properly maintained, there should be little pressure of volume dropped
>across the filter. If you are filtering for solids in the water, yes, it
>should be ahead of the softener. If you are filtering for taste, I'd put it
>after and only on lines getting the water to drink or cook with.

In our house, the kitchen has a single faucet for cold water that does
NOT pass through the softener (to reduce sodium consumption). The toilets
and the outside taps also get unsoftened water. We live in a fairly hard
water area. Filtering for taste would be most sensibly done on human
consumption lines anyway, wouldn't it?


Posted by WDS on February 28, 2007, 7:26 pm


> What is the general opinion on installing a filter
> like this before this softener?? Should I remove it??

That's the right spot for it; you have the same setup we have.


Page 1 of 2       1 2 > last >>
Similar ThreadsPosted
Do we need a water softener or filter or ???? September 16, 2006, 11:10 am
Water softener *and* filter? March 29, 2007, 10:39 am
new water filter/softener system help November 9, 2007, 8:12 pm
House air Filter December 6, 2007, 8:31 am
Whole House Water Filter? March 28, 2006, 11:41 pm
Whole House Water Filter July 10, 2007, 12:35 pm
Whole house water filter March 18, 2008, 9:01 pm
Water filter for whole house humidifier July 19, 2008, 12:33 pm
Whirlpool Whole House Water Filter November 12, 2005, 8:46 am
Old house with gas furnace but no filter question January 12, 2008, 2:24 pm

Contact Us | Privacy Policy

XML SitemapXML Sitemap