Home Page link

basement humidity (do I need dehumidifier and, if so, would this setup work well)

Home Repair - - If it ain't broken, don't fix it. Otherwise look here. 

Page 3 of 4       < 1 2 3 > last >> Bookmark this page:  YahooMyWeb Yahoo!  Google Google  Windows Live Favorites Windows Live  del.icio.us del.icio.us  digg digg  Add to Netscape Netscape
Subject Author Date
basement humidity (do I need dehumidifier and, if so, would this setup work well) jay 06-17-2005
If you were  Registered and logged in, you could reply and use other advanced thread options
Posted by Stretch on June 21, 2005, 8:56 pm
Normally running the furnace fan constantly to reduce humidity during
the summer is a bad idea. I did it in my house as a test, using data
loggers to measure and record relative humidity. When I ran the blower
constantly one summer, it raised the relative humidity 10% to 15% over
letting it run just when the compressor run. TThe extra relative
humidity is from water re-evaporating from the cooling coil and drain
pan.

But I live in Myrtle Beach, SC and humidity is a big problem here.
Since you are measuring the humidity in the rest of the house and it is
staying at an acceptable level. I would say that it is OK to continue
to do so. Just continue to monitor the humidity in the basement and
house. Do whatever works in your climate and your house. The furnace
blower should use less electricity than a dehumidifier.

Stretch


Tankless Water Heaters 468x60
Posted by on June 24, 2005, 11:26 am

>So far I can keep the Basement's humdiity level below 60% as long as I leave
>the blower motor on the Furnace/AC system turned on all the time. This
>causes some of the basement air to circulate throughout the rest of the
>house (with the rest of the house still having humidity below 50%). Would
>I be better off with a dehumidifier rather than leaving the blower motor
>on all summer?

A dehumidifier would add significant heat to the house in summertime...

Here's a calc for the minimum basement slab temp needed to keep a basement
less than 60% RH for a typical year in Baltimore, using long-term monthly
weather data, assuming a fairly airtight house. It looks like the basement
has no problem staying below 60% in wintertime (months 1-4 and 11-12 below),
when outdoor air is dry and the 55.3 F ground supplies enough heat to make
the natural slab temp more than the min slab temp required for 60% RH, given
the moisture in outdoor air.

Psat = e^(17.8653-9621/(460+53.2)) = 0.413 "Hg at 53.2 F and 100% RH in
January, and the vapor pressure of outdoor air with a w = 0.0025 humidity
ratio is Pa = 29.921/(0.62198/w+1) = 0.120 "Hg, so RH = 100Pa/Psat = 29%,
approximately, for a slab that doesn't store moisture.

20 ASLAB=1000'slab area (ft^2)
30 RGRND=10'R-value of deep ground (h-F-ft^2/Btu)
40 TGRND=55.3'deep ground temp (F)
50 CLEAK=10'air leakage rate (cfm)
60 RHMAX=60'max basement relative humidity (%)
70 TAC=80'AC temp (F)
80 RAC=50'AC RH (%)
90 DATA 31.8,.0025,34.8,.0027,44.1,.0037,53.4,.0052,63.4,.0083,72.5,.0115
100 DATA 77.0,.0134,75.6,.0131,68.5,.0106,56.6,.0070,46.8,.0048,36.7,.0032
110 DIM T(12),W(12)
120 FOR M=1 TO 12'month
130 READ T(M),W(M)'average outdoor temp and humidity ratio
140 PA=29.921/(.62198/W(M)+1)'vapor pressure of outdoor air ("Hg)
150 TSMIN=9621/(17.863-LOG(100*PA/RHMAX))-460'min winter slab temp (F)
155 TSNAT=TGRND+(T(M)-TGRND)/(1/CLEAK+RGRND/ASLAB)*RGRND/ASLAB'nat slab temp
160 PRINT M,T(M),TSMIN,TSNAT
170 NEXT

month outdoor min slab natural slab
air (F) temp (F) temp (F)

1 31.8 34.03717 53.16364
2 34.8 35.98914 53.43637
3 44.1 44.13639 54.28182
4 53.4 53.22431 55.12728

The average daily max in May (month 5 below) is 74.2 F. A 66.2 F slab might
lose 24h(66.2-55.3)1000ft^2/R10 = 26K Btu/day to the ground, which might
come from a minimal 230 kWh/mo of indoor electrical use or a 90 W 2470 cfm
intake window fan running 26K/(2470(74.2-70)) = 2.5 hours per day, or less,
on a dry that's warmer and drier than an average May day.

5 63.4 66.21149 56.03636

It looks like AC will help for the next 3 months, with basement-house air
circulation, which would reduce the AC load. At 80 F and 50% RH, a 400 cfm
basement return would make the slab about 55.3+(80-55.3)(1/400+0.01)0.01
= 75.1. With Pa = 0.5e^(17.863-9621/(460+80)) = 0.524 "Hg indoors and Psat
= e^(17.863-9621/(460+75.1)) = 0.890 "Hg near the slab, RH = 100Pa/Psat = 59%
in the basement, approximately. The slab might give (75.1-55.3)1000ft^2/R10
= 1980 Btu/h of sensible cooling.

6 72.5 75.61597 56.86364
7 77 80.12378 57.27273
8 75.6 79.4524 57.14546

The average daily max in September (month 9) is 78.5. This might be another
ventilation month, or an air conditioning month, if it's warmer than average,
or a dehumidification month, if it's cooler.

9 68.5 73.23895 56.5

The average daily max in October is 67.3, so it's a dehumidification month,
with possible help from ventilation.

10 56.6 61.41242 55.41818

And we might do nothing again in months 11 and 12.

11 46.8 51.05957 54.52727
12 36.7 40.35092 53.60909

A TMY2 hourly simulation would show less energy use, since some days are drier
and/or warmer than average in winter and drier and/or cooler in summer. And
concrete can store lots of water, about RH/2K % by weight, in RH% air, and
it takes little additional house heat to reduce the basement RH and dry out
the concrete and desirably increase the house RH in wintertime. A 4"x1000ft^2
50K pound slab can slowly store and evaporate (0.03-0.01)50K = 1000 pints of
water as the RH of the basement air rises from 30 to 60% and falls back again.

Hour-by-hour smart ventilation controls that manage heat and moisture storage
in a basement might reduce the AC and heating load and eliminate the need for
a dehumidifier.

Nick


Posted by on June 24, 2005, 6:11 pm
>The average daily max in September (month 9) is 78.5. This might be another
>ventilation month, or an air conditioning month, if it's warmer than average,
>or a dehumidification month, if it's cooler.

month outdoor min slab nat slab
temp (F) temp (F) temp (F)

9 68.5 73.23895 56.5

We might automatically change a $69 window AC from AC to dehumidification and
back by adding a box around the outside with a $50 2 W (Honeywell 6161B1000)
motorized damper with a hinge h at the top that opens for AC and closes for
dehumidification, with horizontal partitions p and one-way passive plastic
film dampers Di and Do on each side of the AC in the window mount flanges.
It might look like this in the AC damper position, viewed in a fixed font:

--------
ceiling |
|
| window
|
|
---|---------------------h---damper--- (AC)
| |. | .
| |.Do f c| .
| |. a o| => .
| | n n| .
| | d| .
| |--------p------|--p--.
| .| condenser | .
| Di.| inlet air | <= .
| .| | .
------------------------- (dehum)
|
|
|
floor |
--------------

The exterior damper would close and the passive interior dampers would open
in the dehum (heat pump) position, as the condenser fan makes in-house air
pressure and flow above and out-house suction and flow below:

--------
ceiling |
|
| window
|
|
---|---------------------h............ (AC)
| |. | |
| / .Do f c| |
|/ . a o| => d
| | n n| a
| | d| m
| |--------p------|--p--p
| .| condenser | e
| Di. \ inlet air | <= r
| . \ | |
------------------------- (dehum)
|
|
|
floor |
--------------

It might look like this from the inside:

| |
| window |
|-------------------------------------------------|
| ----- | | |
| | | | | |
| | | | | |
| | Do | | | |
| | | | | |
| | | | | |
| --p-- | AC | --p-- |
| | | | | |
| | | | | |
| | | | Di | |
| | | | | |
| | | | | |
| | | ----- |
| | | |
-------------------------------------------------

It might look like this from above:


--------------------damper-----------------------
| |
| |
| p |
| |
| |
| ----------------------------- |
| | | |
| | | |
| | | |
| | | |
| p | | p |
| | | |
| | | |
| | | |
| | AC | |
| | | |
| | | |
| | | |
| | | |
| | | |
| | | |
-------------Do-------------------------------------Di---------
| |
| |
-----------------------------

Nick


Posted by RobertPatrick on June 24, 2005, 6:57 pm
nicksanspam@ece.villanova.edu wrote in

>
>>So far I can keep the Basement's humdiity level below 60% as long as I
>>leave the blower motor on the Furnace/AC system turned on all the
>>time. This causes some of the basement air to circulate throughout
>>the rest of the house (with the rest of the house still having
>>humidity below 50%). Would I be better off with a dehumidifier rather
>>than leaving the blower motor on all summer?
>
> A dehumidifier would add significant heat to the house in
> summertime...
>
> Here's a calc for the minimum basement slab temp needed to keep a
> basement less than 60% RH for a typical year in Baltimore, using
> long-term monthly weather data, assuming a fairly airtight house. It
> looks like the basement has no problem staying below 60% in wintertime
> (months 1-4 and 11-12 below), when outdoor air is dry and the 55.3 F
> ground supplies enough heat to make the natural slab temp more than
> the min slab temp required for 60% RH, given the moisture in outdoor
> air.
>
> Psat = e^(17.8653-9621/(460+53.2)) = 0.413 "Hg at 53.2 F and 100% RH
> in January, and the vapor pressure of outdoor air with a w = 0.0025
> humidity ratio is Pa = 29.921/(0.62198/w+1) = 0.120 "Hg, so RH =
> 100Pa/Psat = 29%, approximately, for a slab that doesn't store
> moisture.
>
> 20 ASLAB=1000'slab area (ft^2)
> 30 RGRND=10'R-value of deep ground (h-F-ft^2/Btu)
> 40 TGRND=55.3'deep ground temp (F)
> 50 CLEAK=10'air leakage rate (cfm)
> 60 RHMAX=60'max basement relative humidity (%)
> 70 TAC=80'AC temp (F)
> 80 RAC=50'AC RH (%)
> 90 DATA
> 31.8,.0025,34.8,.0027,44.1,.0037,53.4,.0052,63.4,.0083,72.5,.0115 100
> DATA 77.0,.0134,75.6,.0131,68.5,.0106,56.6,.0070,46.8,.0048,36.7,.0032
> 110 DIM T(12),W(12)
> 120 FOR M=1 TO 12'month
> 130 READ T(M),W(M)'average outdoor temp and humidity ratio
> 140 PA=29.921/(.62198/W(M)+1)'vapor pressure of outdoor air ("Hg)
> 150 TSMIN=9621/(17.863-LOG(100*PA/RHMAX))-460'min winter slab temp (F)
> 155 TSNAT=TGRND+(T(M)-TGRND)/(1/CLEAK+RGRND/ASLAB)*RGRND/ASLAB'nat
> slab temp 160 PRINT M,T(M),TSMIN,TSNAT
> 170 NEXT
>
> month outdoor min slab natural slab
> air (F) temp (F) temp (F)
>
> 1 31.8 34.03717 53.16364
> 2 34.8 35.98914 53.43637
> 3 44.1 44.13639 54.28182
> 4 53.4 53.22431 55.12728
>
> The average daily max in May (month 5 below) is 74.2 F. A 66.2 F slab
> might lose 24h(66.2-55.3)1000ft^2/R10 = 26K Btu/day to the ground,
> which might come from a minimal 230 kWh/mo of indoor electrical use or
> a 90 W 2470 cfm intake window fan running 26K/(2470(74.2-70)) = 2.5
> hours per day, or less, on a dry that's warmer and drier than an
> average May day.
>
> 5 63.4 66.21149 56.03636
>
> It looks like AC will help for the next 3 months, with basement-house
> air circulation, which would reduce the AC load. At 80 F and 50% RH, a
> 400 cfm basement return would make the slab about
> 55.3+(80-55.3)(1/400+0.01)0.01 = 75.1. With Pa =
> 0.5e^(17.863-9621/(460+80)) = 0.524 "Hg indoors and Psat =
> e^(17.863-9621/(460+75.1)) = 0.890 "Hg near the slab, RH = 100Pa/Psat
> = 59% in the basement, approximately. The slab might give
> (75.1-55.3)1000ft^2/R10 = 1980 Btu/h of sensible cooling.
>
> 6 72.5 75.61597 56.86364
> 7 77 80.12378 57.27273
> 8 75.6 79.4524 57.14546
>
> The average daily max in September (month 9) is 78.5. This might be
> another ventilation month, or an air conditioning month, if it's
> warmer than average, or a dehumidification month, if it's cooler.
>
> 9 68.5 73.23895 56.5
>
> The average daily max in October is 67.3, so it's a dehumidification
> month, with possible help from ventilation.
>
> 10 56.6 61.41242 55.41818
>
> And we might do nothing again in months 11 and 12.
>
> 11 46.8 51.05957 54.52727
> 12 36.7 40.35092 53.60909
>
> A TMY2 hourly simulation would show less energy use, since some days
> are drier and/or warmer than average in winter and drier and/or cooler
> in summer. And concrete can store lots of water, about RH/2K % by
> weight, in RH% air, and it takes little additional house heat to
> reduce the basement RH and dry out the concrete and desirably increase
> the house RH in wintertime. A 4"x1000ft^2 50K pound slab can slowly
> store and evaporate (0.03-0.01)50K = 1000 pints of water as the RH of
> the basement air rises from 30 to 60% and falls back again.
>
> Hour-by-hour smart ventilation controls that manage heat and moisture
> storage in a basement might reduce the AC and heating load and
> eliminate the need for a dehumidifier.
>
> Nick
>
>

Dry heat feels better than humidity + heat. It's very humid here and it
makes the heat feel even worse.

Posted by blueman on July 12, 2005, 12:18 am


nicksanspam@ece.villanova.edu writes:
>
> >So far I can keep the Basement's humdiity level below 60% as long as I leave
> >the blower motor on the Furnace/AC system turned on all the time. This
> >causes some of the basement air to circulate throughout the rest of the
> >house (with the rest of the house still having humidity below 50%). Would
> >I be better off with a dehumidifier rather than leaving the blower motor
> >on all summer?
>
> A dehumidifier would add significant heat to the house in summertime...
>
> Here's a calc for the minimum basement slab temp needed to keep a basement
> less than 60% RH for a typical year in Baltimore, using long-term monthly
> weather data, assuming a fairly airtight house. It looks like the basement
> has no problem staying below 60% in wintertime (months 1-4 and 11-12 below),
> when outdoor air is dry and the 55.3 F ground supplies enough heat to make
> the natural slab temp more than the min slab temp required for 60% RH, given
> the moisture in outdoor air.
>
> Psat = e^(17.8653-9621/(460+53.2)) = 0.413 "Hg at 53.2 F and 100% RH in
> January, and the vapor pressure of outdoor air with a w = 0.0025 humidity
> ratio is Pa = 29.921/(0.62198/w+1) = 0.120 "Hg, so RH = 100Pa/Psat = 29%,
> approximately, for a slab that doesn't store moisture.
>
> 20 ASLAB=1000'slab area (ft^2)
> 30 RGRND=10'R-value of deep ground (h-F-ft^2/Btu)
> 40 TGRND=55.3'deep ground temp (F)
> 50 CLEAK=10'air leakage rate (cfm)
> 60 RHMAX=60'max basement relative humidity (%)
> 70 TAC=80'AC temp (F)
> 80 RAC=50'AC RH (%)
> 90 DATA 31.8,.0025,34.8,.0027,44.1,.0037,53.4,.0052,63.4,.0083,72.5,.0115
> 100 DATA 77.0,.0134,75.6,.0131,68.5,.0106,56.6,.0070,46.8,.0048,36.7,.0032
> 110 DIM T(12),W(12)
> 120 FOR M=1 TO 12'month
> 130 READ T(M),W(M)'average outdoor temp and humidity ratio
> 140 PA=29.921/(.62198/W(M)+1)'vapor pressure of outdoor air ("Hg)
> 150 TSMIN=9621/(17.863-LOG(100*PA/RHMAX))-460'min winter slab temp (F)
> 155 TSNAT=TGRND+(T(M)-TGRND)/(1/CLEAK+RGRND/ASLAB)*RGRND/ASLAB'nat slab temp
> 160 PRINT M,T(M),TSMIN,TSNAT
> 170 NEXT
>
> month outdoor min slab natural slab
> air (F) temp (F) temp (F)
>
> 1 31.8 34.03717 53.16364
> 2 34.8 35.98914 53.43637
> 3 44.1 44.13639 54.28182
> 4 53.4 53.22431 55.12728
>
> The average daily max in May (month 5 below) is 74.2 F. A 66.2 F slab might
> lose 24h(66.2-55.3)1000ft^2/R10 = 26K Btu/day to the ground, which might
> come from a minimal 230 kWh/mo of indoor electrical use or a 90 W 2470 cfm
> intake window fan running 26K/(2470(74.2-70)) = 2.5 hours per day, or less,
> on a dry that's warmer and drier than an average May day.
>
> 5 63.4 66.21149 56.03636
>
> It looks like AC will help for the next 3 months, with basement-house air
> circulation, which would reduce the AC load. At 80 F and 50% RH, a 400 cfm
> basement return would make the slab about 55.3+(80-55.3)(1/400+0.01)0.01
> = 75.1. With Pa = 0.5e^(17.863-9621/(460+80)) = 0.524 "Hg indoors and Psat
> = e^(17.863-9621/(460+75.1)) = 0.890 "Hg near the slab, RH = 100Pa/Psat = 59%
> in the basement, approximately. The slab might give (75.1-55.3)1000ft^2/R10
> = 1980 Btu/h of sensible cooling.
>
> 6 72.5 75.61597 56.86364
> 7 77 80.12378 57.27273
> 8 75.6 79.4524 57.14546
>
> The average daily max in September (month 9) is 78.5. This might be another
> ventilation month, or an air conditioning month, if it's warmer than average,
> or a dehumidification month, if it's cooler.
>
> 9 68.5 73.23895 56.5
>
> The average daily max in October is 67.3, so it's a dehumidification month,
> with possible help from ventilation.
>
> 10 56.6 61.41242 55.41818
>
> And we might do nothing again in months 11 and 12.
>
> 11 46.8 51.05957 54.52727
> 12 36.7 40.35092 53.60909
>
> A TMY2 hourly simulation would show less energy use, since some days are drier
> and/or warmer than average in winter and drier and/or cooler in summer. And
> concrete can store lots of water, about RH/2K % by weight, in RH% air, and
> it takes little additional house heat to reduce the basement RH and dry out
> the concrete and desirably increase the house RH in wintertime. A 4"x1000ft^2
> 50K pound slab can slowly store and evaporate (0.03-0.01)50K = 1000 pints of
> water as the RH of the basement air rises from 30 to 60% and falls back again.
>
> Hour-by-hour smart ventilation controls that manage heat and moisture storage
> in a basement might reduce the AC and heating load and eliminate the need for
> a dehumidifier.
>
> Nick

Not sure I understand this, but am I right in interpreting that you
are basically saying that a dehumidifier is going to be relatively
helpless against a cold slab with warm, humid outside air?
(Plus we have the added comlication of dampness (not puddles) seeping
in during rainstorms?

So if a large cold slab stores so much moisture, what is the best
thing to do?
- Heat the slab?
- Circulate *in* hot air from outside (even if it is humid) to
attempt to heat up the slab?
- ????


Page 3 of 4       < 1 2 3 > last >>
Similar ThreadsPosted
Basement bathroom setup/drain February 12, 2007, 1:31 pm
Original Basement humidity post comment. June 19, 2005, 4:46 pm
Opinions wanted for basement humidity levels May 13, 2006, 2:01 pm
new dehumidifier for basement? April 10, 2008, 4:46 pm
Dehumidifier and basement wall August 24, 2006, 5:44 pm
Basement dehumidifier, heat, etc June 14, 2007, 9:36 am
Dehumidifier in a New England's basement during the winter? October 3, 2005, 4:33 am
basement dehumidifier, condensate pump March 14, 2006, 2:42 pm
does radiant heat work under carpet in basement? March 10, 2007, 9:20 pm
Paint Sprayer Setup February 10, 2006, 12:10 pm

Contact Us | Privacy Policy

XML SitemapXML Sitemap