Home Page link

problem removing cover from old shower drain trap in floor, can't continue project without loosening it

Home Repair - - If it ain't broken, don't fix it. Otherwise look here. 

Bookmark this page:  YahooMyWeb Yahoo!  Google Google  Windows Live Favorites Windows Live  del.icio.us del.icio.us  digg digg  Add to Netscape Netscape
Subject Author Date
problem removing cover from old shower drain trap in floor, can't continue project without loosening it K Ruck 07-01-2005
If you were  Registered and logged in, you could reply and use other advanced thread options
Posted by K Ruck on July 1, 2005, 9:02 pm
I've removed about half my (small) bathroom floor, which had decades of
water damage and needed to be replaced before I could put in a tile floor.

The shower doesn't go to a P-trap; it goes to an old cannister trap that is
under the floorboards (or was, until I removed them). The cap is a 5" metal
disk with a 1.25" hex-nut shaped protrusion in the center. The trap itself
appears to be lead, and the incoming and outgoing pipes in it are lead as
well. They go under the tub (which isn't part of my remodeling plans) so I
want to just remove the cap and replace it with a flush cap so I can tile
around it, and leave it as-is.

The problem is when I torque it with my plumbing wrench (with enough force
to leave teeth marks on the hex nut) the only movement I get is the input
and output lead pipes twisting slightly. Not a good idea. So my next thought
was to heat the top of the trap a little (like running a jar under hot water
to loosen the lid), but I'm afraid I'll just melt the lead and be completely
in trouble.

Does anyone have experience with these old traps, especially stuck ones,
that could give me any suggestions on how to safely remove the cap?

Many. many thanks
Keith



Plumbing 468x60
Posted by Speedy Jim on July 1, 2005, 10:09 pm
K Ruck wrote:
> I've removed about half my (small) bathroom floor, which had decades of
> water damage and needed to be replaced before I could put in a tile floor.
>
> The shower doesn't go to a P-trap; it goes to an old cannister trap that is
> under the floorboards (or was, until I removed them). The cap is a 5" metal
> disk with a 1.25" hex-nut shaped protrusion in the center. The trap itself
> appears to be lead, and the incoming and outgoing pipes in it are lead as
> well. They go under the tub (which isn't part of my remodeling plans) so I
> want to just remove the cap and replace it with a flush cap so I can tile
> around it, and leave it as-is.
>
> The problem is when I torque it with my plumbing wrench (with enough force
> to leave teeth marks on the hex nut) the only movement I get is the input
> and output lead pipes twisting slightly. Not a good idea. So my next thought
> was to heat the top of the trap a little (like running a jar under hot water
> to loosen the lid), but I'm afraid I'll just melt the lead and be completely
> in trouble.
>
> Does anyone have experience with these old traps, especially stuck ones,
> that could give me any suggestions on how to safely remove the cap?
>
> Many. many thanks
> Keith
>
>

It is called a "drum trap". They are now specifically prohibted.
Usually made of cast iron, but 100 yrs ago could have been
fabricated as lead with lead waste piping.

The cap is often a thin brass fitting. A very sharp cold chisel
will cut thru it (or use a drill to swiss-cheese the thing).
Then it can be collapsed and removed.

I don't quite understand why the cover must be removed.
If it is the hex "nut" that is in the way, saw it off.
(No guarantee that the nut isn't hollow...)

Jim

Posted by K Ruck on July 1, 2005, 10:17 pm
My goal was to replace the cap (which appears to be the only part of it that
isn't lead, it looks almost chrome) with a flush (or inset) cover to be
level with the floor, while still looking nice. I'm not good enough to cut
the hex off cleanly and smoothly (assuming it isn't hollow) without having
to spend a whole lot of time with my dremel and other tools trying to make
it smooth, and even then, I'd lose any ability to get traction in case I
ever did need to remove the cover in the future.

I'd consider retrofitting a P-trap, but the iron pipe that the lead goes
into is not easily accessible, and is pointing about 110 degrees away from
the shower drain, so I'd end up having to do some serious re-routing, then
figure out how to get a firm and permanent connection to the iron pipe. Oh,
and the fact that the iron pipe is probably high enough that there isn't
enough rise/run even if I did use a p-trap. :-(

My other option is to hire a professional to come rip out the tub and do
major plumbing, which doesn't sound like it would be within my budget... the
tub is tiled in, so a least the tile and probably part of one wall would
have to come out.

Thanks,
Keith

> K Ruck wrote:
> > I've removed about half my (small) bathroom floor, which had decades of
> > water damage and needed to be replaced before I could put in a tile
floor.
> >
> > The shower doesn't go to a P-trap; it goes to an old cannister trap that
is
> > under the floorboards (or was, until I removed them). The cap is a 5"
metal
> > disk with a 1.25" hex-nut shaped protrusion in the center. The trap
itself
> > appears to be lead, and the incoming and outgoing pipes in it are lead
as
> > well. They go under the tub (which isn't part of my remodeling plans) so
I
> > want to just remove the cap and replace it with a flush cap so I can
tile
> > around it, and leave it as-is.
> >
> > The problem is when I torque it with my plumbing wrench (with enough
force
> > to leave teeth marks on the hex nut) the only movement I get is the
input
> > and output lead pipes twisting slightly. Not a good idea. So my next
thought
> > was to heat the top of the trap a little (like running a jar under hot
water
> > to loosen the lid), but I'm afraid I'll just melt the lead and be
completely
> > in trouble.
> >
> > Does anyone have experience with these old traps, especially stuck ones,
> > that could give me any suggestions on how to safely remove the cap?
> >
> > Many. many thanks
> > Keith
> >
> >
>
> It is called a "drum trap". They are now specifically prohibted.
> Usually made of cast iron, but 100 yrs ago could have been
> fabricated as lead with lead waste piping.
>
> The cap is often a thin brass fitting. A very sharp cold chisel
> will cut thru it (or use a drill to swiss-cheese the thing).
> Then it can be collapsed and removed.
>
> I don't quite understand why the cover must be removed.
> If it is the hex "nut" that is in the way, saw it off.
> (No guarantee that the nut isn't hollow...)
>
> Jim



Posted by Speedy Jim on July 1, 2005, 10:50 pm
K Ruck wrote:

> My goal was to replace the cap (which appears to be the only part of it that
> isn't lead, it looks almost chrome) with a flush (or inset) cover to be
> level with the floor, while still looking nice. I'm not good enough to cut
> the hex off cleanly and smoothly (assuming it isn't hollow) without having
> to spend a whole lot of time with my dremel and other tools trying to make
> it smooth, and even then, I'd lose any ability to get traction in case I
> ever did need to remove the cover in the future.
>
> I'd consider retrofitting a P-trap, but the iron pipe that the lead goes
> into is not easily accessible, and is pointing about 110 degrees away from
> the shower drain, so I'd end up having to do some serious re-routing, then
> figure out how to get a firm and permanent connection to the iron pipe. Oh,
> and the fact that the iron pipe is probably high enough that there isn't
> enough rise/run even if I did use a p-trap. :-(
>
> My other option is to hire a professional to come rip out the tub and do
> major plumbing, which doesn't sound like it would be within my budget... the
> tub is tiled in, so a least the tile and probably part of one wall would
> have to come out.
>
> Thanks,
> Keith


There is a "universal" replacement cover for drum traps.
They are chrome and IIRC have a flush surface with only
a slotted screw recessed in it.

Ask around at a hardware store or plumbing supply house.
I doubt that BigBox would have them, but maybe...
Get a new cover before attacking the old one.
Jim

>
>
>>K Ruck wrote:
>>
>>>I've removed about half my (small) bathroom floor, which had decades of
>>>water damage and needed to be replaced before I could put in a tile
>
> floor.
>
>>>The shower doesn't go to a P-trap; it goes to an old cannister trap that
>
> is
>
>>>under the floorboards (or was, until I removed them). The cap is a 5"
>
> metal
>
>>>disk with a 1.25" hex-nut shaped protrusion in the center. The trap
>
> itself
>
>>>appears to be lead, and the incoming and outgoing pipes in it are lead
>
> as
>
>>>well. They go under the tub (which isn't part of my remodeling plans) so
>
> I
>
>>>want to just remove the cap and replace it with a flush cap so I can
>
> tile
>
>>>around it, and leave it as-is.
>>>
>>>The problem is when I torque it with my plumbing wrench (with enough
>
> force
>
>>>to leave teeth marks on the hex nut) the only movement I get is the
>
> input
>
>>>and output lead pipes twisting slightly. Not a good idea. So my next
>
> thought
>
>>>was to heat the top of the trap a little (like running a jar under hot
>
> water
>
>>>to loosen the lid), but I'm afraid I'll just melt the lead and be
>
> completely
>
>>>in trouble.
>>>
>>>Does anyone have experience with these old traps, especially stuck ones,
>>>that could give me any suggestions on how to safely remove the cap?
>>>
>>>Many. many thanks
>>>Keith
>>>
>>>
>>
>>It is called a "drum trap". They are now specifically prohibted.
>>Usually made of cast iron, but 100 yrs ago could have been
>>fabricated as lead with lead waste piping.
>>
>>The cap is often a thin brass fitting. A very sharp cold chisel
>>will cut thru it (or use a drill to swiss-cheese the thing).
>>Then it can be collapsed and removed.
>>
>>I don't quite understand why the cover must be removed.
>>If it is the hex "nut" that is in the way, saw it off.
>>(No guarantee that the nut isn't hollow...)
>>
>>Jim
>
>
>

Similar ThreadsPosted
drum trap cover February 8, 2008, 4:58 pm
Shower Drain Problem December 2, 2006, 11:27 am
Garage Floor Drain Problem February 18, 2007, 2:09 pm
Unwise to connect 11/4" drain to 11/2" trap? April 16, 2007, 2:40 pm
Busted furnace condensate drain trap November 7, 2006, 5:52 pm
Washing Machine Lint Trap / Drain Protector November 19, 2006, 8:22 pm
Finished Basement: house, drain trap & vent May 31, 2008, 12:24 am
lead (drain) pipe, drum trap questions November 17, 2008, 7:36 am
Re: lead (drain) pipe, drum trap questions November 18, 2008, 11:41 am
Shower Drain Strainer Won't Fit, Part II -- How to Remove a Small Length of a Drain Pipe? February 6, 2007, 9:57 pm

Contact Us | Privacy Policy

XML SitemapXML Sitemap